Towards an Equitable and Just Internet

The Internet is emerging as a central feature of contemporary human life. We use it to access and disseminate information, to communicate and build community, to transact business and to practise democracy. Ever increasing dimensions of our social, economic, cultural and political life are tied to the Internet.

However, the benefits of the Internet - knowledge and power, wealth and influence, are distributed unevenly. A technology built on the egalitarian peer-to-peer principle, ironically, is emerging as a key axis of inequality, an instrument perpetuating and reinforcing longstanding social, economic, cultural and political injustices. Snowden's dramatic exposé of a deep nexus between the US government and a few global corporations to enable global surveillance, confirmed just one aspect of the problem. The truth about the Internet and how its socio-technical architecture is being shaped is considerably more complex and insidious. The rapid colonisation of the Internet by a few monopolizing global corporations, and its governance being subject, in a highly disproportionate manner, to the laws and policy priorities of one country, impacts not just privacy, but a huge range of very important social, economic, cultural and political issues. (To a lesser extent, policy frameworks developed by clubs of rich countries like the the OCED also impact the emerging shape of the Internet.)

Questions of democracy, social justice and equity need to become central to how the Internet, and how an Internet-mediated society, are evolving. The smokescreen of technical-neutrality has prevented for too long a critical, political examination of the social underpinnings of the Internet, its normative boundaries and legalinstitutional frames. In addition, self-serving formulations like 'Multistakeholderism' and 'Internet Freedom', are employed by the status quo to maintain a facade of legitimacy. Beyond the rhetoric, it is clear that the Internet – in its dominance by the powerful, is neither genuinely multi-stakeholder nor genuinely free.

There are foundational questions to be pursued, in this regard : How is the Internet redistributing power and resources? How does this impact those at the margins, those on the peripheries of an increasingly globalised world? How is such redistribution connected to the socio-technical architecture of the Internet? What kind of Internet would promote social justice and equity? What needs to be done to make it more just, more egalitarian? Who governs the Internet, and how can its governance be democratized? From the standpoint of global justice, two urgent priorities lie ahead of us.

1. A progressive conception and vision of the Internet, and
2. A common global ownership of the Internet that protects and promotes its public-ness, and its evolution as a 'global commons'. The Internet was envisaged as a decentralized network, with control from the peripheries. This characteristic of the network is rapidly eroding, What is urgently needed is a recasting of this technical principle into a socio-political framework for a truly people-owned and people-controlled Internet, and one that works for all. The global governance of the Internet requires a proper institutionalization and legal framework incorporating the true spirit of participatory democracy. It should inter alia serve to insulate the Internet both from corporatist and from statist dominations.

An international meeting, entitled 'Towards a Just and Equitable Internet', is envisaged to address the key issues identified above. It will be held in New Delhi, India, on February 14th and 15th, 2013. The meeting will bring together actors engaged in social justice movements and ICT, communication and media rights advocacy to dialogue with some of those already engaged with Internet governance issues, with a view to chart a progressive response to issues related to global governance of the Internet.

Potential outcomes from the meeting include:

1. A 'charter for Internet justice and equity';
2. Specific proposals for democratizing the global governance of the Internet as contributions to the 'Global Multistakeholder Meeting on the Future of Internet Governance' being hosted by Brazilian government in April, 2013, the UN Working Group on Enhanced Cooperation and the WSIS + 10 process.