Centre for Internet & Society

Privacy in Healthcare: Policy Guide

by Tanvi Mani

The Health Policy Guide seeks to understand what are the legal regulations governing data flow in the health sector — particularly hospitals, and how are these regulations implemented. Towards this objective, the research reviews data practices in a variety of public and private hospitals and diagnostics labs. The research is based on legislation, case law, publicly available documents, and anonymous interviews.

Read more →

Learning to Forget the ECJ's Decision on the Right to be Forgotten and its Implications

by Divij Joshi

“The internet never forgets” is a proposition which is equally threatening and promising.

Read more →

“OTTs Eating Into Our Revenue”: Telcos in India

by Geetha Hariharan

On August 5, 2014, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India organised a seminar on a regulatory framework for Over-The-Top services. This is a lay discussion of the Seminar and its focus on matters crucial to telecom, the Internet and the existing regulatory framework.

Read more →

Second Privacy and Surveillance Roundtable

by Anandini K Rathore

On July 4, 2014, the Centre for Internet and Society in association with the Cellular Operators Association of India organized a privacy roundtable at the India International Centre. The primary aim was to gain inputs on what would constitute an ideal surveillance regime in India.

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 19) – Lobsang Sangay

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Lobsang Sangay, Prime Minister of the Central Tibetan Administration, as part of the Cybersecurity Series.

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 18) – Lobsang Gyatso Sither

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Lobsang Gyatso Sither, Tibetan field coordinator and activist, as part of the Cybersecurity Series.

Read more →

UK’s Interception of Communications Commissioner — A Model of Accountability

by Joe Sheehan

The United Kingdom maintains sophisticated electronic surveillance operations through a number of government agencies, ranging from military intelligence organizations to police departments to tax collection agencies. However, all of this surveillance is governed by one set of national laws outlining specifically what surveillance agencies can and cannot do.

Read more →

Private Censorship and the Right to Hear

by Chinmayi Arun

Very little recourse is available against publishers or intermediaries if these private parties censor an author’s content unreasonably.

Read more →

First Privacy and Surveillance Roundtable

by Anandini K Rathore

The Privacy and Surveillance Roundtables are a CIS initiative, in partnership with the Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI), as well as local partners. From June 2014 – November 2014, CIS and COAI will host seven Privacy and Surveillance Roundtable discussions across multiple cities in India. The Roundtables will be closed-door deliberations involving multiple stakeholders.

Read more →

GNI and IAMAI Launch Interactive Slideshow Exploring Impact of India's Internet Laws

by Jyoti Panday

The Global Network Initiative and the Internet and Mobile Association of India have come together to explain how India’s Internet and technology laws impact economic innovation and freedom of expression.

Read more →

Delhi High Court Orders Blocking of Websites after Sony Complains Infringement of 2014 FIFA World Cup Telecast Rights

by Anubha Sinha

Of late the Indian judiciary has been issuing John Doe orders to block websites, most recently in Multi Screen Media v. Sunit Singh and Others. The order mandated blocking of 472 websites, out of which approximately 267 websites were blocked as on July 7, 2014. This trend is an extremely dangerous one because it encourages flagrant censorship by intermediaries based on a judicial order which does not provide for specific blocking of a URL, instead provides for blocking of the entire website.

Read more →

FOEX Live

by Geetha Hariharan

Selections of news on online freedom of expression and digital technology from across India (and some parts of the world)

Read more →

Free Speech and Surveillance

by Gautam Bhatia

Gautam Bhatia examines the constitutionality of surveillance by the Indian state.

Read more →

Facebook and its Aversion to Anonymous and Pseudonymous Speech

by Jessamine Mathew

Jessamine Mathew explores Facebook's "real name" policy and its implications for the right to free speech.

Read more →

The Constitutionality of Indian Surveillance Law: Public Emergency as a Condition Precedent for Intercepting Communications

by Bedavyasa Mohanty

Bedavyasa Mohanty analyses the nuances of interception of communications under the Indian Telegraph Act and the Indian Post Office Act. In this post he explores the historical bases of surveillance law in India and examines whether the administrative powers of intercepting communications are Constitutionally compatible.

Read more →

Models for Surveillance and Interception of Communications Worldwide

by Bedavyasa Mohanty

This is an evaluation of laws and practices governing surveillance and interception of communications in 9 countries. The countries evaluated represent a diverse spectrum not only in terms of their global economic standing but also their intrusive surveillance capabilities. The analysis is limited to the procedural standards followed by these countries for authorising surveillance and provisions for resolving interception related disputes.

Read more →

Reading the Fine Script: Service Providers, Terms and Conditions and Consumer Rights

by Jyoti Panday

This year, an increasing number of incidents, related to consumer rights and service providers, have come to light. This blog illustrates the facts of the cases, and discusses the main issues at stake, namely, the role and responsibilities of providers of platforms for user-created content with regard to consumer rights.

Read more →

ICANN’s Documentary Information Disclosure Policy – I: DIDP Basics

by Vinayak Mithal

In a series of blogposts, Vinayak Mithal analyses ICANN's reactive transparency mechanism, comparing it with freedom of information best practices. In this post, he describes the DIDP and its relevance for the Internet community.

Read more →

An Evidence based Intermediary Liability Policy Framework: Workshop at IGF

by Jyoti Panday

CIS is organising a workshop at the Internet Governance Forum 2014. The workshop will be an opportunity to present and discuss ongoing research on the changing definition of intermediaries and their responsibilities across jurisdictions and technologies and contribute to a comprehensible framework for liability that is consistent with the capacity of the intermediary and with international human-rights standards.

Read more →

Free Speech and Civil Defamation

by Gautam Bhatia

Does defamation become a tool in powerful hands to suppress criticism? Gautam Bhatia examines the strict and unrealistic demands of defamation law, and concludes that defamation suits are a weapon to silence dissent and bad press.

Read more →

FOEX Live: June 16-23, 2014

by Geetha Hariharan

A weekly selection of news on online freedom of expression and digital technology from across India (and some parts of the world).

Read more →

IANA Transition: Suggestions for Process Design

by Smarika Kumar

With analysis of community-input and ICANN processes, Smarika Kumar offers concrete suggestions for process design. She urges the Indian government to take a stronger position in matters of IANA transition.

Read more →

CIS Policy Brief: IANA Transition Fundamentals & Suggestions for Process Design

by Geetha Hariharan

In March 2014, the US government announced that it would transfer oversight of IANA functions to an as-yet-indeterminate global multi-stakeholder body. This policy brief, written by Smarika Kumar and Geetha Hariharan, explains the process concisely.

Read more →

Understanding IANA Stewardship Transition

by Smarika Kumar

Smarika Kumar describes the process of the IANA stewardship transition, and enumerates what the NTIA announcement does and does not do.

Read more →

WSIS+10 High Level Event: A Bird's Eye Report

by Geetha Hariharan

The WSIS+10 High Level was organised by the ITU and collaborative UN entities on June 9-13, 2014. It aimed to evaluate the progress on implementation of WSIS Outcomes from Geneva 2003 and Tunis 2005, and to envision a post-2015 Development Agenda. Geetha Hariharan attended the event on CIS' behalf.

Read more →

Free Speech and Source Protection for Journalists

by Gautam Bhatia

Gautam Bhatia explores journalistic source protection from the perspective of the right to freedom of speech & expression. In this post, he articulates clearly the centrality of source protection to press freedoms, and surveys the differing legal standards in the US, Europe and India.

Read more →

UN Human Rights Council urged to protect human rights online

by Geetha Hariharan

63 civil society groups urged the UN Human Rights Council to address global challenges to freedom of expression, privacy and other human rights on the Internet. Centre for Internet & Society joined in the statement, delivered on behalf of the 63 groups by Article 19.

Read more →

Vodafone Report Explains Government Access to Customer Data

by Joe Sheehan

Vodafone Group PLC, the world’s second largest mobile carrier, released a report on Friday, June 6 2014 disclosing to what extent governments can request their customers’ data.

Read more →

Multi-stakeholder Models of Internet Governance within States: Why, Who & How?

by Geetha Hariharan

Internet governance, for long a global exercise, has found new awareness within national frameworks in recent times. Especially relevant for developing countries, effective national IG mechanisms are important to raise awareness and ensure multi-stakeholder participation at technical, infrastructural and public policy levels.

Read more →

FOEX Live: June 8-15, 2014

by Geetha Hariharan

A weekly selection of news on online freedom of expression and digital technology from across India (and some parts of the world). Please email relevant news/cases/incidents to geetha[at]cis-india.org.

Read more →

A Review of the Functioning of the Cyber Appellate Tribunal and Adjudicatory Officers under the IT Act

by Divij Joshi

Tribunals and quasi-judicial bodies are a regular feature of the Indian judicial system, as they provide for easier and less onerous methods for dispute resolution, especially disputes which relate to technical areas and often require technical knowledge and familiarity with specialised factual scenarios.

Read more →

Content Removal on Facebook — A Case of Privatised Censorship?

by Jessamine Mathew

Any activity on Facebook, be it creating an account, posting a picture or status update or creating a group or page, is bound by Facebook’s Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. These contain a list of content that is prohibited from being published on Facebook which ranges from hate speech to pornography to violation of privacy.

Read more →

Free Speech and Contempt of Courts – II: Article 19(1)(a) and Indian Law

by Gautam Bhatia

Gautam Bhatia continues his examination of free speech implications of the law of contempt: the power that equips courts to "protect the dignity of the Bench".

Read more →

Comments to ICANN Supporting the DNS Industry in Underserved Regions

by Jyoti Panday

Towards exploring ideas and strategies to help promote the domain name industry in regions that have typically been underserved, ICANN published a call for public comments on May 14, 2014. In particular, ICANN sought comments related to existing barriers to Registrar Accreditation and operation and suggestions on how these challenges might be mitigated. CIS contributed to the comments on this report, which will be used to determine next steps to support the domain name industry in underserved regions.

Read more →

CIS Comments: Enhancing ICANN Accountability

by Geetha Hariharan

On May 6, 2014, ICANN published a call for public comments on "Enhancing ICANN Accountability". This comes in the wake of the IANA stewardship transition spearheaded by ICANN and related concerns of ICANN's external and internal accountability mechanisms. Centre for Internet and Society contributed to the call for comments.

Read more →

Free Speech and Contempt of Court – I: Overview

by Gautam Bhatia

Gautam Bhatia explores an under-theorised aspect of India's free speech jurisprudence: the contempt power that equips courts to "protect the dignity of the Bench". In this introductory post, he examines jurisprudence from the US and England to inform our analysis of Indian law.

Read more →

FOEX Live: June 1-7, 2014

by Geetha Hariharan

A weekly selection of news on online freedom of expression and digital technology from across India (and some parts of the world).

Read more →

Search and Seizure and the Right to Privacy in the Digital Age: A Comparison of US and India

by Divij Joshi

The development of information technology has transformed the way in which individuals make everyday transactions and communicate with the world around us. These interactions and transactions are recorded and stored – constantly available for access by the individual and the company through which the service was used.

Read more →

Two Arguments Against the Constitutionality of Section 66A

by Gautam Bhatia

Gautam Bhatia explores the constitutionality of Section 66A in light of recent events.

Read more →

FOEX Live: May 28-29, 2014

by Geetha Hariharan

A selection of news from across India with a bearing on online freedom of expression and use of digital technology

Read more →

FOEX Live: May 26-27, 2014

by Geetha Hariharan

A selection of news from across India implicating online freedom of expression and use of digital technology

Read more →

Legislating for Privacy - Part II

by Bhairav Acharya

Apart from the conflation of commercial data protection and privacy, the right to privacy bill has ill-informed and poorly drafted provisions to regulate surveillance.

Read more →

Net Neutrality, Free Speech and the Indian Constitution – III: Conceptions of Free Speech and Democracy

by Gautam Bhatia

In this 3 part series, Gautam Bhatia explores the concept of net neutrality in the context of Indian law and the Indian Constitution.

Read more →

European Court of Justice rules Internet Search Engine Operator responsible for Processing Personal Data Published by Third Parties

by Jyoti Panday

The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled that an "an internet search engine operator is responsible for the processing that it carries out of personal data which appear on web pages published by third parties.” The decision adds to the conundrum of maintaining a balance between freedom of expression, protecting personal data and intermediary liability.

Read more →

Net Freedom Campaign Loses its Way

by Sunil Abraham

A recent global meet was a victory for governments and the private sector over civil society interests.

Read more →

Networks: What You Don’t See is What You (for)Get

by Nishant Shah

When I start thinking about DML (digital media and learning) and other such “networks” that I am plugged into, I often get a little confused about what to call them.

Read more →

The Embodiment of the Right to Privacy within Domestic Legislation

by Tanvi Mani

The Right to Privacy is a pivotal construct, essential to the actualization of justice, fairness and equity within any democratic society. It is an instrument used to secure the boundaries of an individual’s personal space, in his interaction with not only the rest of society but also the State.

Read more →

Net Neutrality, Free Speech and the Indian Constitution - II

by Gautam Bhatia

In this 3 part series, Gautam Bhatia explores the concept of net neutrality in the context of Indian law and the Indian Constitution.

Read more →

NETmundial Day 2

by Achal Prabhala

Fadi Chehade, the ICANN boss, closed NETmundial 2014 with these words "In Africa we say if you want to go first, go alone, but if you want to go far, go together." He should have added: And if you want to go nowhere, go multi-stakeholder.

Read more →

NETmundial: Tracking *Multistakeholder* across Contributions

by Sumandro Chattapadhyay

This set of analysis of the contributions submitted to NETmundial 2014 is part of the effort by the Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore, India, to enable productive discussions of the critical internet governance issues at the meeting and elsewhere.

Read more →

Brazil passes Marco Civil; the US-FCC Alters its Stance on Net Neutrality

by Geetha Hariharan

Hopes for the Internet rise and fall rapidly. Yesterday, on April 23, 2014, Marco Civil da Internet, the Brazilian Bill of Internet rights, was passed by the Brazilian Senate into law.

Read more →

NETmundial Day 1

by Achal Prabhala

Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff's speech at the opening of NETmundial in São Paulo was refreshingly free of the UN-speak that characterised virtually every single other presentation this morning. The experience of sitting for five hours in a room where the word "multi-stakeholder" is repeated at the rate of five mentions per minute is not for the faint-hearted; it almost makes you wish for more of the straight-talking tough-love of people like Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt.

Read more →

NETmundial Transcript Archive

by Pranesh Prakash

We are archiving the live transcript from the NETmundial meeting (April 23-24, 2014).

Read more →

NETmundial Roadmap: Defining the Roles of Stakeholders in Multistakeholderism

by Jyoti Panday

NETmundial, one of the most anticipated events in the Internet governance calendar, will see the global community convening at Sao Paolo, with an aim to establish 'strategic guidelines related to the use and development of the Internet in the world.' This post analyses the submissions at NETmundial that focused on Roadmap, towards an understanding of stakeholder roles in relation to specific governance functions and highlighting the political, technical and architectural possibilities that lie ahead.

Read more →

NETmundial Day 0

by Achal Prabhala

Day O of NETmundial began at Arena NetMundial, an alternative-ish, Brazilian counterpart to the official "multistakeholder" meeting being organised at the very expensive Grand Hyatt. Arena NETmundial began today and will extend until the last day of NETmundial; it's being organised at the very democratic Centro Cultural São Paulo - free to all, no registration required - and offers space for a whole host of organised and spontaneous activity.

Read more →

Accountability of ICANN

by Smarika Kumar

The issue of how to ensure the legitimacy and accountability of ICANN is a concern which finds voice in many of the proposals. Four broad stands can be gleaned from the submissions to NETmundial '14 on this issue.

Read more →

NETmundial - Word Clouds of Contributions by Types of Organisation

by Sumandro Chattapadhyay

This set of analysis of the contributions submitted to NETmundial 2014 is part of the effort by the Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore, India, to enable productive discussions of the critical internet governance issues at the meeting and elsewhere.

Read more →

NETmundial - Which Countries Have Not Submitted Contributions to NETmundial?

by Sumandro Chattapadhyay

This set of analysis of the contributions submitted to NETmundial 2014 is part of the effort by the Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore, India, to enable productive discussions of the critical internet governance issues at the meeting and elsewhere.

Read more →

NETmundial - Contributions by Types of Organisation

by Sumandro Chattapadhyay

This set of analysis of the contributions submitted to NETmundial 2014 is part of the effort by the Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore, India, to enable productive discussions of the critical internet governance issues at the meeting and elsewhere.

Read more →

NETmundial - Contributions by Countries of Origin

by Sumandro Chattapadhyay

This set of analysis of the contributions submitted to NETmundial 2014 is part of the effort by the Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore, India, to enable productive discussions of the critical internet governance issues at the meeting and elsewhere.

Read more →

NETmundial - Comparing Appearance of Fifty Most Frequent Words

by Sumandro Chattapadhyay

This set of analysis of the contributions submitted to NETmundial 2014 is part of the effort by the Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore, India, to enable productive discussions of the critical internet governance issues at the meeting and elsewhere.

Read more →

Banking Policy Guide

by Elonnai Hickok

To gain a practical perspective on the existing banking practices and policies in India in this project, an empirical study of five separate and diverse banks has been conducted. The forms, policy documents, and other relevant and available documents of these banks have been analysed in this project.

Read more →

NETmundial and Suggestions for IANA Administration

by Smarika Kumar

Following NTIA's announcement to give up control over critical Internet functions, the discussion on how that role should be filled has gathered steam across the Internet governance space.

Read more →

Principles for Internet Governance: NETmundial 2014 — What do the Contributions Reveal?

by Geetha Hariharan

The Global Multi-stakeholder Meeting on the Future of Internet Governance (NETmundial) is scheduled for April 23-24, 2014. Towards its stated end of establishing "strategic guidelines related to the use and development of the Internet in the world", NETmundial sought contributions from stakeholders around the world on two topics: (1) Set of Internet governance principles; (2) Roadmaps for the further evolution of the Internet governance system.

Read more →

South African Protection of Personal Information Act, 2013

by Divij Joshi

As the rapid spread of technology in developing countries allows exponentially increasing availability of and access to personal data through automatic data processing, governments are beginning to recognize the necessity to evolve policies addressing data security and privacy concerns.

Read more →

Privacy Law in India: A Muddled Field - I

by Bhairav Acharya

The absence of a statute expressing the legislative will of a democracy to forge a common understanding of privacy is a matter of concern, says BHAIRAV ACHARYA in the first of a two part series.

Read more →

Very Big Brother

by Sunil Abraham

The Centre for Internet and Society, the organization I work for, currently serves on a committee established by the Government of India's Department of Biotechnology, Ministry of Science and Technology in January 2013. The committee has been charged with preparing a report on the draft Human DNA Profiling Bill.

Read more →

Report of the Group of Experts on Privacy vs. The Leaked 2014 Privacy Bill

by Elonnai Hickok

Following our previous post comparing the leaked 2014 Privacy Bill with the leaked 2011 Privacy Bill, this post will compare the recommendations provided in the Report of the Group of Experts on Privacy by the Justice AP Shah Committee to the text of the leaked 2014 Privacy Bill. Below is an analysis of recommendations from the Report that are incorporated in the text of the Bill, and recommendations in the Report that are not incorporated in the text of the Bill.

Read more →

Net Neutrality, Free Speech and the Indian Constitution - I

by Gautam Bhatia

In this post, I will explore net neutrality in the context of Indian law and the Indian Constitution.

Read more →

Who Governs the Internet? Implications for Freedom and National Security

by Sunil Abraham

The second half of last year has been quite momentous for Internet governance thanks to Edward Snowden. German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff became aware that they were targets of US surveillance for economic not security reasons. They protested loudly.

Read more →

Between the Local and the Global: Notes Towards Thinking the Nature of Internet Policy

by Nishant Shah

This post by Nishant Shah is part of a series related to the 2014 Milton Wolf Seminar on Media and Diplomacy: The Third Man Theme Revisited: Foreign Policies of the Internet in a Time Of Surveillance and Disclosure, which takes place in Vienna, Austria from March 30 – April 1, 2014.

Read more →

Marco Civil da Internet: Brazil’s ‘Internet Constitution’

by Geetha Hariharan

On March 25, 2014, Brazil's lower house of parliament passed bill no. 2126/2011, popularly known as Marco Civil da Internet. The Marco Civil is a charter of Internet user-rights and service provider responsibilities, committed to freedom of speech and expression, privacy, and accessibility and openness of the Internet. In this post, the author looks at the pros and cons of the bill.

Read more →

Leaked Privacy Bill: 2014 vs. 2011

by Elonnai Hickok

The Centre for Internet and Society has recently received a leaked version of the draft Privacy Bill 2014 that the Department of Personnel and Training, Government of India has drafted.

Read more →

Intermediary Liability Resources

by Elonnai Hickok

We bring you a list of intermediary resources as part of research on internet governance. This blog post will be updated on an ongoing basis.

Read more →

The Age of Shame

by Nishant Shah

The ability to capture private images is breeding a dangerous form of digital shaming. Within the online space, where wonderments often run rife, and conspiracy theories travel at the speed of light, there are many dark recesses where netizens half-jokingly, self-referentially, in a spirit of part-truth, part-exaggeration, often wonder on what the real reason is for the internet to exist.

Read more →

CIS Statement at ICANN 49's Public Forum

by Pranesh Prakash

This was a statement made by Pranesh Prakash at the ICANN 49 meeting (on March 27, 2014), arguing that ICANN's bias towards the North America and Western Europe result in a lack of legitimacy, and hoping that the IANA transition process provides an opportunity to address this.

Read more →

European Union Draft Report Admonishes Mass Surveillance, Calls for Stricter Data Protection and Privacy Laws

by Elonnai Hickok

Ever since the release of the “Snowden files”, the secret documents evidencing the massive scale of surveillance undertaken by America’s National Security Agency and publically released by whistle-blower Edward Snowden, surveillance in the digital age has come to the fore of the global debate on internet governance and privacy.

Read more →

Privacy worries cloud Facebook's WhatsApp Deal

by Sunil Abraham

Privacy activists in the United States have asked the competition regulator or the Federal Trade Commission to put on hold Facebook's acquisition of WhatsApp. Why have they done this when Facebook has promised to leave WhatsApp untouched as a standalone app?

Read more →

Net Neutrality and Privacy

by Divij Joshi

The highly contentious and polarising debate on net-neutrality will have a large impact on shaping the future of the internet and ultimately on the users of the internet. One important issue which needs to be prioritized while debating the necessity or desirability of a legal regime which advocates net-neutrality is its implication on privacy.

Read more →

NTIA to give up control of the Internet's root

by Pranesh Prakash

On Friday evening the U.S. government's National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) announced that it was setting into motion a transition to give up a few powers that it holds over some core Internet functions, and that this would happen by September 2015. Pranesh Prakash provides a brief response to that announcement.

Read more →

New Standard Operating Procedures for Lawful Interception and Monitoring

by Divij Joshi

Government issues new guidelines to TSP’s to assist Lawful Interception and Monitoring.

Read more →

Comparison of Section 35(1) of the Draft Human DNA Profiling Bill and Section 4 of the Identification Act Revised Statute of Canada

by Elonnai Hickok

A comparison of section 35(1) of the Draft Human DNA Profiling Bill, section 4 of the Identification Act, Revised Statute of Canada, and a review of international best practices.

Read more →

Big Democracy, Big Surveillance: India's Surveillance State

by Maria Xynou

In India, surveillance is on the rise by the state to tackle crime and terrorism, and private companies are eager to meet the demand.

Read more →

Surveillance and the Indian Constitution - Part 3: The Public/Private Distinction and the Supreme Court’s Wrong Turn

by Pranesh Prakash

After its decision in Gobind, the Supreme Court's privacy floodgates opened; a series of claims involving private parties came before its docket, and the resulting jurisprudence ended up creating confusion between state-individual surveillance, and individual-individual surveillance.

Read more →

UIDAI Practices and the Information Technology Act, Section 43A and Subsequent Rules

by Elonnai Hickok

UIDAI practices and section 43A of the IT Act are analyzed in this post.

Read more →

Open Call for Comments: The Privacy Protection Bill 2013 drafted by the Centre for Internet and Society

by Bhairav Acharya

The Centre for Internet and Society is announcing an Open Call for Comments to the CIS Privacy Protection Bill 2013.

Read more →

CIS Welcomes 52nd Report on Cyber Crime, Cyber Security, and Right to Privacy

by Elonnai Hickok

The “Fifty Second Report on Cyber Crime, Cyber Security, and Right to Privacy” issued by the 2013 -2014 Standing Committee on Information Technology on February 12th 2014, highlights the urgent need for reform in India’s cyber security framework and the need for the much awaited privacy legislation to be finalized and made into a law.

Read more →

Calcutta High Court Strengthens Whistle Blower Protection

by Divij Joshi

Calcutta High Court has ordered for protection of whistle blower's privacy in its November 20, 2013 order. The court has directed the government to accept RTI applications without the applicant's personal details.

Read more →

Will You be Paid to Post a Picture?

by Nishant Shah

The wave of free information production on the web is on the wane.

Read more →

The Internet Way

by Nishant Shah

Dr. Nishant Shah's review of the book “The Everything Store: Jeff Bezos and the Age of Amazon” by Bantam Press/Random House Group, London was published in Biblio Vol. 19 No.8 (1&2), January – February 2014.

Read more →

February 11: The Day We Fight Back Against Mass Surveillance

by Divij Joshi

The expansive surveillance being perpetuated by governments and corporations is the single biggest threat to individual liberties in the digital age.

Read more →

Video Games: A Case Study of a Cross-cultural Video Collaboration

by Larissa Hjorth and Nishant Shah

A new book focusing on Palestinian artists’ video, edited by Bashir Makhoul and published by Palestinian Art Court- al Hoash, 2013, includes a chapter co-authored by Larissa Hjorth and Nishant Shah.

Read more →

India's Central Monitoring System (CMS): Something to Worry About?

by Maria Xynou

In this article, Maria Xynou presents new information about India's controversial Central Monitoring System (CMS) based on official documents which were shared with the Centre for Internet and Society (CIS). Read this article and gain an insight on how the CMS actually works!

Read more →

Making the Powerful Accountable

by Chinmayi Arun

If powerful figures are not subjected to transparent court proceedings, the opacity in the face of a critical issue is likely to undermine public faith in the judiciary.

Read more →

Surveillance and the Indian Constitution - Part 2: Gobind and the Compelling State Interest Test

by Pranesh Prakash

Gautam Bhatia analyses the first case in which the Supreme Court recognized a constitutional right to privacy, Gobind v. State of Madhya Pradesh, and argues that the holding in that case adopted the three-pronged American test of strict scrutiny, compelling State interest, and narrow tailoring in its approach to privacy violations.

Read more →

Interview with Mathew Thomas from the Say No to UID campaign - UID Court Cases

by Maria Xynou

The Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) recently interviewed Mathew Thomas from the Say No to UID campaign about his ongoing efforts to challenge the UID scheme legally in the Bangalore High Court and Supreme Court of India. Read this interview and gain an interesting insight on recent legal developments with regards to the UID!

Read more →

GNI Assessment Finds ICT Companies Protect User Privacy and Freedom of Expression

by Elonnai Hickok

Elonnai Hickok analyses a public report recently published by GNI on the independent assessment process for Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo. The report finds Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo to be in compliance with the GNI principles on privacy and freedom of expression.

Read more →

Electoral Databases – Privacy and Security Concerns

by Snehashish Ghosh

In this blogpost, Snehashish Ghosh analyzes privacy and security concerns which have surfaced with the digitization, centralization and standardization of the electoral database and argues that even though the law provides the scope for protection of electoral databases, the State has not taken any steps to ensure its safety.

Read more →

Surveillance and the Indian Constitution - Part 1: Foundations

by Pranesh Prakash

In this insightful seven-part series, Gautam Bhatia looks at surveillance and the right to privacy in India from a constitutional perspective, tracing its genealogy through Supreme Court case law and compares it with the law in the USA.

Read more →

Letter requesting public consultation on position of GoI at WGEC

by Snehashish Ghosh

Snehashish Ghosh on behalf of the Centre for Internet and Society sent a letter to the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology, requesting for a public consultation on India's position at the Working Group on Enhanced Cooperation (WGEC).

Read more →

Big Brother is watching you

by Chinmayi Arun

India has no requirements of transparency whether in the form of disclosing the quantum of interception or in the form of notification to people whose communication was intercepted.

Read more →

India's Identity Crisis

by Malavika Jayaram

Malavika Jayaram's article was published in 2013 Internet Monitor Annual Report: Reflections on the Digital World, published by Harvard's Berkman Center for Internet and Society.

Read more →

Brochures from Expos on Smart Cards, e-Security, RFID & Biometrics in India

by Maria Xynou

Electronics Today organised a series of expos on smart cards, e-security, RFID and biometric technology in Delhi on 16-18 October 2013. The Centre for Internet and Society is sharing the brochures it collected from these public expos for research purposes.

Read more →

Misuse of Surveillance Powers in India (Case 1)

by Pranesh Prakash

In this series of blog posts, Pranesh Prakash looks at a brief history of misuse of surveillance powers in India. He notes that the government's surveillance powers have been freqently misused, very often without any kind of judicial or political redressal. This, he argues, should lead us as concerned citizens to demand a scaling down of the government's surveillance powers and pass laws to put it place more robust oversight mechanisms.

Read more →

I Just Pinged to Say Hello

by Nishant Shah

A host of social networks find us more connected than ever before, but leave us groping for words in the digital space.

Read more →

CIS Supports the UN Resolution on “The Right to Privacy in the Digital age”.

by Elonnai Hickok

The United Nations adopted the resolution on the right to privacy recently. It recognised privacy as a human right, integral to the right to free expression, and also declared that mass surveillance could have negative impacts on human rights.

Read more →

Seventh Privacy Round-table

by Elonnai Hickok

On October 19, 2013, the Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) in collaboration with the Federation for Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry, the Data Security Council of India, and Privacy International held a “Privacy Round-table” in New Delhi at the FICCI Federation House.

Read more →

Why 'Facebook' is More Dangerous than the Government Spying on You

by Maria Xynou

In this article, Maria Xynou looks at state and corporate surveillance in India and analyzes why our "choice" to hand over our personal data can potentially be more harmful than traditional, top-down, state surveillance. Read this article and perhaps reconsider your "choice" to use social networking sites, such as Facebook.

Read more →

First Look: CIS Cybersecurity documentary film

by Purba Sarkar

CIS presents the trailer of its documentary film DesiSec: Cybersecurity & Civil Society in India

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 12) - Namita Malhotra

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Namita Malhotra, researcher and lawyer at Alternative Law Forum, Bangalore, as part of the Cybersecurity Series.

Read more →

Interview with Caspar Bowden - Privacy Advocate and former Chief Privacy Adviser at Microsoft

by Maria Xynou

Maria Xynou recently interviewed Caspar Bowden, an internationally renowned privacy advocate and former Chief Privacy Adviser at Microsoft. Read this exciting interview and gain an insight on India's UID and CMS schemes, on the export of surveillance technologies, on how we can protect our data in light of mass surveillance and much much more!

Read more →

Open Secrets

by Nishant Shah

We need to think of privacy in different ways — not only as something that happens between people, but between you and corporations.

Read more →

Mapping Digital Media: Broadcasting, Journalism and Activism in India: A Public Consultation

by Samantha Cassar

Lawyers, researchers, journalists and activists gathered on Sunday, October 27, 2013 at the Bangalore International Centre in response to India’s country report on Mapping Digital Media, which examines citizen’s access to quality news and information across different industries, and impacts on media freedoms as a result of digitisation. Respondents examined themes related to regulation, journalism and activism, and engaging discussions took place among attendees.

Read more →

Spy Files 3: WikiLeaks Sheds More Light On The Global Surveillance Industry

by Maria Xynou

In this article, Maria Xynou looks at WikiLeaks' latest Spy Files and examines the legality of India's surveillance technologies, as well as their potential connection with India's Central Monitoring System (CMS) and implications on human rights.

Read more →

What India can Learn from the Snowden Revelations

by Elonnai Hickok

Big Brother is watching, across cyberspace and international borders. Meanwhile, the Indian government has few safeguards in theory and fewer in practice. There’s no telling how prevalent or extensive Indian surveillance really is.

Read more →

An Interview with Jacob Kohnstamm, Dutch Data Protection Authority and Chairman of the Article 29 Working Party

by Elonnai Hickok

The Centre for Internet and Society interviewed Jacob Kohnstamm, Dutch Data Protection Authority and Chairman of the Article 29 Working Party.

Read more →

Interview with Dr. Alexander Dix - Berlin Data Protection and Freedom of Information Commissioner

by Maria Xynou

Maria Xynou recently interviewed Berlin's Data Protection and Freedom of Information Commissioner: Dr. Alexander Dix. View this interview and gain an insight on recommendations for better data protection in India!

Read more →

Open Letter to Members of the European Parliament of the Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs Committee

by Elonnai Hickok

An open letter was sent to the Members of the European Parliament of the Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs Committee on the proposed EU Regulation. The letter was apart of an initiative that Privacy International and a number of other NGO's are undertaking.

Read more →

Tweets from Bali IGF 2013

by Pranesh Prakash

CIS is logging all tweets with the words "igf2013", "igf13", "igf", "bestbits", and "genderit" during the Intenet Governance Forum going on in the Bali this week, and making it available in downloadable files.

Read more →

Interview with the Tactical Technology Collective on Privacy and Surveillance

by Maria Xynou

The Centre for Internet and Society recently interviewed Anne Roth from the Tactical Technology Collective in Berlin. View this interview and gain an insight on why we should all "have something to hide"!

Read more →

Interview with Bruce Schneier - Internationally Renowned Security Technologist

by Maria Xynou

Maria Xynou recently interviewed Bruce Schneier on privacy and surveillance. View this interview and gain an insight on why we should all "have something to hide"!

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 11) - Anja Kovacs

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Anja Kovacs, researcher and activist, and director of the Internet Democracy, Project as part of the Cybersecurity Series.

Read more →

Interview with Big Brother Watch on Privacy and Surveillance

by Maria Xynou

Maria Xynou interviewed Emma Carr, the Deputy Director of Big Brother Watch, on privacy and surveillance. View this interview and gain an insight on why we should all "have something to hide"!

Read more →

Concerns Regarding DNA Law

by Bhairav Acharya

Recently, a long government process to draft a law to permit the collection, processing, profiling, use and storage of human DNA is nearing conclusion. There are several concerns with this government effort. Below, we present broad-level issues to be kept in mind while dealing with DNA law.

Read more →

The India Privacy Monitor Map

by Maria Xynou

The Centre for Internet and Society has started the first Privacy Watch in India! Check out our map which includes data on the UID, NPR and CCTNS schemes, as well as on the installation of CCTV cameras and the use of drones throughout the country.

Read more →

Re: The Human DNA Profiling Bill, 2012

by Bhairav Acharya

This short note speaks to legal issues arising from the proposed Human DNA Profiling Bill, 2012 ("DBT Bill") that was circulated drafted under the aegis of the Department of Biotechnology of the Ministry of Science and Technology, Government of India, which seeks to collect human DNA samples, profile them and store them. These comments are made clause-by-clause against the DBT Bill.

Read more →

An Analysis of the Cases Filed under Section 46 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 for Adjudication in the State of Maharashtra

by Bhairav Acharya

This is a brief review of some of the cases related to privacy filed under section 46 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 ("the Act") seeking adjudication for alleged contraventions of the Act in the State of Maharashtra.

Read more →

A Privacy Meeting with the Federal Trade Commission in New Delhi

by Elonnai Hickok

On September 20, the Centre for Internet and Society held a roundtable meeting with Betsy Broder, Counsel for International Consumer Protection, and Sarah Schroeder, Attorney, Bureau of Consumer Protection, Federal Trade Commission (FTC), United States. The meeting took place at the Imperial, Janpath, New Delhi and discussed both the U.S framework to privacy and potential frameworks and challenges to privacy in India.

Read more →

Privacy (Protection) Bill, 2013: Updated Third Draft

by Bhairav Acharya

The Centre for Internet and Society has been researching privacy in India since 2010 with the objective of raising public awareness around privacy, completing in depth research, and driving a privacy legislation in India. As part of this work, we drafted the Privacy (Protection) Bill, 2013.

Read more →

The National Cyber Security Policy: Not a Real Policy

by Bhairav Acharya

Cyber security in India is still a nascent field without an organised law and policy framework. Several actors participate in and are affected by India's still inchoate cyber security regime. The National Cyber Security Policy (NCSP) presented the government and other stakeholders with an opportune moment to understand existing legal limitations before devising a future framework. Unfortunately, the NCSP's poor drafting and meaningless provisions do not advance the field.

Read more →

CIS and International Coalition Calls upon Governments to Protect Privacy

by Elonnai Hickok

The Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) along with the International Coalition has called upon governments across the globe to protect privacy.

Read more →

The Central Monitoring System: Some Questions to be Raised in Parliament

by Bhairav Acharya

The following are some model questions to be raised in the Parliament regarding the lack of transparency in the central monitoring system.

Read more →

The National Privacy Roundtable Meetings

by Bhairav Acharya

The Centre for Internet & Society ("CIS"), the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry ("FICCI"), the Data Security Council of India ("DSCI") and Privacy International are, in partnership, conducting a series of national privacy roundtable meetings across India from April to October 2013. The roundtable meetings are designed to discuss possible frameworks to privacy in India.

Read more →

Transparency Reports — A Glance on What Google and Facebook Tell about Government Data Requests

by Prachi Arya

Transparency Reports are a step towards greater accountability but how efficacious are they really?

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 10) - Lawrence Liang

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Lawrence Liang, researcher and lawyer, and co-founder of Alternative Law Forum, Bangalore, as part of the Cybersecurity Series.

Read more →

Privacy Law Must Fit the Bill

by Sunil Abraham

The process of updating Indian privacy policy has gained momentum ever since the launch of the UID project and also the leak of the Radia tapes. The Department of Personnel and Training has lead the drafting of privacy bill for the last three years. This bill will ideally articulate privacy principles and establish the office of the privacy commissioner and most importantly have an over-riding effect over 50 odd existing laws, rules and policies with privacy implications.

Read more →

An Interview with Suresh Ramasubramanian

by Elonnai Hickok

Suresh Ramasubramanian is the ICS Quality Representative - IBM SmartCloud at IBM. We from the Centre for Internet and Society conducted an interview on cybersecurity and issues in the Cloud.

Read more →

Report on the Sixth Privacy Roundtable Meeting, New Delhi

by Prachi Arya

In 2013 the Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) drafted the Privacy Protection Bill as a citizens' version of a privacy legislation for India. Since April 2013, CIS has been holding Privacy Roundtables in collaboration with Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) and DSCI, with the objective of gaining public feedback to the Privacy Protection Bill and other possible frameworks for privacy in India. The following is a report on the Sixth Privacy Roundtable held in New Delhi on August 24, 2013.

Read more →

Out of the Bedroom

by Nishant Shah

We have shared it with our friends. We have watched it with our lovers. We have discussed it with our children and talked about it with our partners. It is in our bedrooms, hidden in sock drawers. It is in our laptops, in a folder marked "Miscellaneous". It is in our cellphones and tablets, protected under passwords. It is the biggest reason why people have learned to clean their browsing history and cookies from their browsers.

Read more →

Freedom from Monitoring: India Inc Should Push For Privacy Laws

by Sunil Abraham

More surveillance than absolutely necessary actually undermines the security objective.

Read more →

FinFisher in India and the Myth of Harmless Metadata

by Maria Xynou

In this article, Maria Xynou argues that metadata is anything but harmless, especially since FinFisher — one of the world's most controversial types of spyware — uses metadata to target individuals.

Read more →

Ethical Issues in Open Data

by Kovey Coles

On August 1, 2013, I took part in a web meeting, organized and hosted by Tim Davies of the World Wide Web foundation. The meeting, titled “Ethical issues in Open Data,” had an agenda focused around privacy considerations in the context of the open data movement.

Read more →

'Ethical Hacker' Saket Modi Calls for Stronger Cyber Security Discussions

by Kovey Coles

Twenty-two year old Saket Modi is the CEO and co-founder of Lucideus, a leading cyber security company in India which claims to have worked with 4 out of 5 top global e-commerce companies, 4 out of 10 top IT companies in the world, and 3 out of 5 top banks of the Asia Pacific.

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 9) - Saikat Datta

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Saikat Datta, Resident Editor of DNA, Delhi, as part of the Cybersecurity Series.

Read more →

Guidelines for the Protection of National Critical Information Infrastructure: How Much Regulation?

by Jonathan Diamond

July has been a busy month for cyber security in India. Beginning with the release of the country’s first National Cyber Security Policy on July 2 and followed just this past week by a set of guidelines for the protection of national critical information infrastructure (CII) developed under the direction of the National Technical Research Organization (NTRO), India has made respectable progress in its thinking on national cyber security.

Read more →

More than a Hundred Global Groups Make a Principled Stand against Surveillance

by Elonnai Hickok

For some time now there has been a need to update understandings of existing human rights law to reflect modern surveillance technologies and techniques.

Read more →

India's National Cyber Security Policy in Review

by Jonathan Diamond

Earlier this month, the Department of Electronics and Information Technology released India’s first National Cyber Security Policy. Years in the making, the Policy sets high goals for cyber security in India and covers a wide range of topics, from institutional frameworks for emergency response to indigenous capacity building.

Read more →

The Audacious ‘Right to Be Forgotten’

by Kovey Coles

There has long been speculation over the permanency of our online presence. Posting about excessively-personal details, commenting in a way which is later embarrassing, being caught in unflattering public photos; to our chagrin, all of these unfortunate situations often persist on the web, and can continue to haunt us in future years.

Read more →

Report on the 5th Privacy Round Table meeting

by Maria Xynou

This report entails an overview of the discussions and recommendations of the fifth Privacy Round Table in Calcutta, on 13th July 2013.

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 8) - Jeff Moss

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Jeff Moss, Chief Security Officer for ICANN, as part of the Cybersecurity Series.

Read more →

You Have the Right to Remain Silent

by Nishant Shah

Reflecting upon the state of freedom of speech and expression in India, in the wake of the shut-down of the political satire website narendramodiplans.com.

Read more →

Parsing the Cyber Security Policy

by Chinmayi Arun

An effective cyber-security policy must keep up with the rapid evolution of technology, and must never become obsolete. The standard-setting and review bodies will therefore need to be very nimble, says Chinmayi Arun.

Read more →

CII Conference on "ACT": Achieve Cyber Security Together"

by Kovey Coles

The Confederation of Indian Industries (CII) organized a conference on facing cyber threats and challenges at Hotel Hilton in Chennai on July 13, 2013. Kovey Coles attended this conference and shares a summary of the event in this blog post.

Read more →

DSCI Best Practices Meet 2013

by Kovey Coles

The DSCI Best Practices Meet 2013 was organized on July 12, 2013 at Hyatt Regency, Anna Salai in Chennai. Kovey Coles attended the meet and shares a summary of the happenings in this blog post.

Read more →

Interview with Mr. Reijo Aarnio - Finnish Data Protection Ombudsman

by Maria Xynou

Maria Xynou recently interviewed Mr. Reijo Aarnio, the Finnish Data Protection Ombudsman, at the CIS' 5th Privacy Round Table. View this interview and gain an insight on recommendations for better data protection in India!

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 7) - Jochem de Groot

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Jochem de Groot, former policy advisor to the Netherlands government, as part of the Cybersecurity Series

Read more →

Can India Trust Its Government on Privacy?

by Pranesh Prakash

In response to criticisms of the Centralized Monitoring System, India’s new surveillance program, the government could contend that merely having the capability to engage in mass surveillance won’t mean that it will. Officials will argue that they will still abide by the law and will ensure that each instance of interception will be authorized.

Read more →

How Surveillance Works in India

by Pranesh Prakash

When the Indian government announced it would start a Centralized Monitoring System in 2009 to monitor telecommunications in the country, the public seemed unconcerned. When the government announced that the system, also known as C.M.S., commenced in April, the news didn’t receive much attention.

Read more →

Moving Towards a Surveillance State

by Srinivas Atreya

The cyberspace is a modern construct of communication and today, a large part of human activity takes place in cyberspace. It has become the universal platform where business is executed, discourse is conducted and personal information is exchanged. However, the underbelly of the internet is also seen to host activities and persons who are motivated by nefarious intent.

Read more →

India:Privacy in Peril

by Bhairav Acharya

The danger of mass surveillance in India is for real. The absence of a regulating law is damning for Indians who want to protect their privacy against the juggernaut of state and private surveillance.

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 4) - Marietje Schaake

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Marietje Schaake, member of the European parliament, as part of the Cybersecurity Series

Read more →

The Difficult Balance of Transparent Surveillance

by Kovey Coles

Is it too much to ask for transparency in data surveillance? On occasion, companies like Microsoft, Facebook, and the other silicon valley giants would say no. When customers join these services, each company provides their own privacy statement which assures customers of the safety and transparency that accompanies their personal data.

Read more →

Privacy Protection Bill, 2013 (With Amendments based on Public Feedback)

by Elonnai Hickok

In 2013 CIS drafted the Privacy Protection Bill as a citizens' version of a privacy legislation for India. Since April 2013, CIS has been holding Privacy Roundtables in collaboration with FICCI and DSCI, with the objective of gaining public feedback to the Privacy Protection Bill and other possible frameworks for privacy in India.

Read more →

SEBI and Communication Surveillance: New Rules, New Responsibilities?

by Kovey Coles

In this blog post, Kovey Coles writes about the activities of the Securities Exchange Board of India (SEBI), discusses the importance of call data records (CDRs), and throws light on the significant transition in governmental leniency towards access to private records.

Read more →

The State is Snooping: Can You Escape?

by Snehashish Ghosh

Blanket surveillance of the kind envisaged by India's Centralized Monitoring System achieves little, but blatantly violates the citizen's right to privacy; Snehashish Ghosh explores why it may be dangerous and looks at potential safeguards against such intrusion.

Read more →

Open Letter to Prevent the Installation of RFID tags in Vehicles

by Maria Xynou

The Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) has sent this open letter to the Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers (SIAM) to urge them not to intall RFID tags in vehicles in India.

Read more →

Way to watch

by Chinmayi Arun

The domestic surveillance regime in India lacks adequate safeguards.

Read more →

Report on the 4th Privacy Round Table meeting

by Maria Xynou

This report entails an overview of the discussions and recommendations of the fourth Privacy Round Table in Mumbai, on 15th June 2013.

Read more →

Interview with the Citizen Lab on Internet Filtering in India

by Maria Xynou

Maria Xynou recently interviewed Masashi Crete-Nishihata and Jakub Dalek from the Citizen Lab on internet filtering in India. View this interview and gain an insight on Netsweeper and FinFisher!

Read more →

Interview with Mr. Billy Hawkes - Irish Data Protection Commissioner

by Maria Xynou

Maria Xynou recently interviewed Mr. Billy Hawkes, the Irish Data Protection Commissioner, at the CIS´ 4th Privacy Round Table meeting. View this interview and gain an insight on recommendations for data protection in India!

Read more →

Open Letter to "Not" Recognize India as Data Secure Nation till Enactment of Privacy Legislation

by Elonnai Hickok

India shouldn't be granted the status of "data secure nation" by Europe until it enacts a suitable privacy legislation, points out the Centre for Internet and Society in this open letter.

Read more →

World Wide Rule

by Nishant Shah

Nishant Shah's review of Schmidt and Cohen's book was published in the Indian Express on June 14, 2013.

Read more →

Indian surveillance laws & practices far worse than US

by Pranesh Prakash

Explosive would be just the word to describe the revelations by National Security Agency (NSA) whistleblower Edward Snowden.

Read more →

India Subject to NSA Dragnet Surveillance! No Longer a Hypothesis — It is Now Officially Confirmed

by Maria Xynou

As of last week, it is officially confirmed that the metadata of everyone´s communications is under the NSA´s microscope. In fact, the leaked data shows that India is one of the countries which is under NSA surveillance the most!

Read more →

CIS Cybersecurity Series (Part 1) - Christopher Soghoian

by Purba Sarkar

CIS interviews Christopher Soghoian, cybersecurity researcher and activist, as part of the Cybersecurity Series

Read more →

A Technological Solution to the Challenges of Online Defamation

by Eduardo Bertoni

When people are insulted or humiliated on the Internet and decide to take legal action, their cases often follow a similar trajectory.

Read more →

Comparative Analysis of DNA Profiling Legislations from Across the World

by Srinivas Atreya

With the growing importance of forensic data in law enforcement and research, many countries have recognized the need to regulate the collection and use of forensic data and maintain DNA databases. Across the world around 60 countries maintain DNA databases which are generally regulated by specific legislations. Srinivas Atreya provides a broad overview of the important provisions of four different legislations which can be compared and contrasted with the Indian draft bill.

Read more →

Report on the 3rd Privacy Round Table meeting

by Maria Xynou

This report entails an overview of the discussions and recommendations of the third Privacy Round Table meeting in Chennai, on 18th May 2013.

Read more →

Google Policy Fellowship Programme: Call for Applications

by Prasad Krishna

The Centre for Internet & Society (CIS) is inviting applications for the Google Policy Fellowship programme. Google is providing a USD 7,500 stipend to the India Fellow, who will be selected by July 1, 2013.

Read more →

The Surveillance Industry in India: At Least 76 Companies Aiding Our Watchers!

by Maria Xynou

Maria Xynou is conducting research on surveillance technology companies operating in India. So far, 76 companies have been detected which are currently producing and selling different types of surveillance technology. This post entails primary data on the first ever investigation of the surveillance industry in India. Check it out!

Read more →

IT (Amendment) Act, 2008, 69B Rules: Draft and Final Version Comparison

by Jadine Lannon

Jadine Lannon has performed a clause-by-clause comparison of the Draft 69B Rules and official 69B Rules under Section 69B in order to better understand how the two are similar and how they differ. Notes have been included on some changes we deemed to be important.

Read more →

IT (Amendment) Act, 2008, 69 Rules: Draft and Final Version Comparison

by Jadine Lannon

Jadine Lannon has performed a clause-by-clause comparison of the Draft 69 Rules and official 69 Rules under Section 69B in order to better understand how the two are similar and how they differ. Very brief notes have been included on some changes we deemed to be important.

Read more →

Indian Telegraph Act, 1885, 419A Rules and IT (Amendment) Act, 2008, 69 Rules

by Jadine Lannon

Jadine Lannon has performed a clause-by-clause comparison of the 419A Rules of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 and the 69 Rules under Section 69 of the Information Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008 in order to better understand how the two are similar and how they differ. Though they are from different Acts entirely, the Rules are very similar. Notes have been included on some changes we deemed to be important.

Read more →

IT (Amendment) Act, 2008, 69A Rules: Draft and Final Version Comparison

by Jadine Lannon

Jadine Lannon has performed a clause-by-clause comparison of the 69A draft rules and 69A rules for Section 69A of the IT Act in order to better understand how the two differ. While there has been reshuffling of the clauses in the official rules, the content itself has not changed significantly. Notes have been included on some changes we deemed to be important.

Read more →

Report on the 2nd Privacy Round Table meeting

by Maria Xynou

This post entails a report on the second Privacy Round Table meeting which took place on 20th April 2013.

Read more →

Report on the 1st Privacy Round Table meeting

by Maria Xynou

This report entails an overview of the discussions and recommendations of the first Privacy Round Table meeting in New Delhi, on 13th April 2013.

Read more →

India's 'Big Brother': The Central Monitoring System (CMS)

by Maria Xynou

In this post, Maria Xynou looks at India´s Central Monitoring System (CMS) project and examines whether it can target individuals´ communications data, regardless of whether they are involved in illegal activity.

Read more →

Off the Record

by Nishant Shah

Social networks track our world but not relationships. We live in a world where things happen. And yet, with the presence of digital objects, the things that happen have increased in intensity and volume.

Read more →

Comments on the Information Technology (Electronic Service Delivery) Rules, 2011

by Bhairav Acharya

Bhairav Acharya on behalf of the Centre for Internet and Society prepared the following comments on the Information Technology (Electronic Services Delivery) Rules, 2011. These were submitted to the Committee on Subordinate Legislation of the 15th Lok Sabha. These were submitted to the Committee on Subordinate Legislation of the 15th Lok Sabha.

Read more →

WGIG+8: Stock-Taking, Mapping, and Going Forward

by Pranesh Prakash

On February 27, 2013, the Centre for Internet and Society conducted a workshop on the Working Group on Internet Governance report, titled "WGIG+8: Stock-Taking, Mapping, and Going Forward" at the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) + 10 meeting at Fontenoy Building, conference room # 7, UNESCO Headquarters, Paris from 9.30 a.m. to 11.00 a.m.

Read more →

Comments on the Information Technology (Reasonable Security Practices and Procedures and Sensitive Personal Data or Information) Rules, 2011

by Bhairav Acharya

Bhairav Acharya on behalf of the Centre for Internet and Society prepared the following comments on the Sensitive Personal Data Rules. These were submitted to the Committee on Subordinate Legislation of the 15th Lok Sabha.

Read more →

Comments on the Information Technology (Guidelines for Cyber Cafe) Rules, 2011

by Bhairav Acharya

Bhairav Acharya on behalf of the Centre for Internet and Society submitted the following comments on the Information Technology (Guidelines for Cyber Cafe Rules), 2011.

Read more →

The Criminal Law Amendment Bill 2013 — Penalising 'Peeping Toms' and Other Privacy Issues

by Divij Joshi

The pending amendments to the Indian Penal Code, if passed in their current format, would be a huge boost for individual physical privacy by criminalising stalking and sexually-tinted voyeurism and removing the ambiguities in Indian law which threaten the privacy and dignity of individuals.

Read more →

India's Biometric Identification Programs and Privacy Concerns

by Divij Joshi

The invasiveness of individual identification coupled with the fallibility of managing big data which biometric identification presents poses a huge risk to individual privacy in India.

Read more →

What’s In a Name? — DNS Singularity of ICANN and The Gold Rush

by Sharath Chandra Ram

March 2013 being the 28th birthday of the first ever registered Internet domain as well as the exigent launch of the Trademark Clearing House disguised as a milestone in rights protection by the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) for it’s new gTLD program, Sharath Chandra Ram, dissects the transitory role of ICANN from being a technical outfit to the Boardroom Big Brother of Internet Governance.

Read more →

Microsoft releases its first report on data requests by law enforcement agencies around the world

by Maria Xynou

In this post, the Centre for Internet and Society presents Microsoft´s report on law enforcement requests, with a focus on data requested by Indian law enforcement agencies.

Read more →

CIS Welcomes Standing Committee Report on IT Rules

by Pranesh Prakash

The Centre for Internet and Society welcomes the report by the Standing Committee on Subordinate Legislation, in which it has lambasted the government and has recommended that the government amend the Rules it passed in April 2011 under section 79 of the Information Technology Act.

Read more →

Driving in the Surveillance Society: Cameras, RFID tags and Black Boxes...

by Maria Xynou

In this post, Maria Xynou looks at red light cameras, RFID tags and black boxes used to monitor vehicles in India.

Read more →

The Privacy (Protection) Bill 2013: A Citizen's Draft

by Bhairav Acharya

The Centre for Internet and Society has been researching privacy in India since 2010 with the objective of raising public awareness around privacy, completing in depth research, and driving a privacy legislation in India. As part of this work, Bhairav Acharya has drafted the Privacy (Protection) Bill 2013.

Read more →

Human DNA Profiling Bill 2012 Analysis

by Jeremy Gruber

Jeremy Gruber from the Council for Responsible Genetics, US provides an analysis of the Human DNA Profiling Bill, 2012. He says that India’s updated 2012 Human DNA Profiling Bill offers largely superficial changes from its predecessor, the Draft DNA Profiling Bill, 2007.

Read more →

Workshop on the Unique Identity Number (UID), the National Population Register (NPR) and Governance: What will happen to our data?

by Maria Xynou

On March 2nd, 2013, the Centre for Internet and Society and the Say No to UID campaign organized a workshop to discuss the present state of the UID and NPR schemes. Some of the questions which were addressed included ´How do the UID and NPR impact citizenship´, ´Why and how is national security linked to UID/NPR´, and ´What is the relationship between UID and Big Data´.

Read more →

Hacking without borders: The future of artificial intelligence and surveillance

by Maria Xynou

In this post, Maria Xynou looks at some of DARPA´s artificial intelligence surveillance technologies in regards to the right to privacy and their potential future use in India.

Read more →

A Comparison of the Draft DNA Profiling Bill 2007 and the Draft Human DNA Profiling Bill 2012

by Maria Xynou

In this post, Maria Xynou gives us a comparison of the Draft DNA Profiling Bill 2007 and the Draft Human DNA Profiling Bill 2012.

Read more →

Summary of the CIS workshop on the Draft Human DNA Profiling Bill 2012

by Maria Xynou

On March 1st, 2013, the Centre for Internet and Society organized a workshop which analysed the April 2012 draft Human DNA Profiling Bill and its potential implications on human rights in India.

Read more →

Unique Identification Scheme (UID) & National Population Register (NPR), and Governance

by Elonnai Hickok

This post examines the UID, NPR and Governance as it exists in India. The background note gives a summary of what is the NPR, the legal grounding of NPR, its objectives, and the information which could be collected under the NPR. The post also throws light on the UID, its objectives, process of enrollment in UID, how UID is being adopted by different states in India, and finally the differences and controversies in UID and NPR.

Read more →

Draft Human DNA Profiling Bill (April 2012): High Level Concerns

by Elonnai Hickok

In 2007 the Draft Human DNA Profiling Bill was piloted by the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics, with the objective of regulating the use of DNA for forensic and other purposes. In February 2012 another draft of the Bill was leaked. The February 2012 Bill was drafted by the Department of Biotechnology. Another working draft of the Bill was created in April 2012. The most recent version of the Bill seeks to create DNA databases at the state, regional, and national level.

Read more →

An Introduction to Bitfilm & Bitcoin in Bangalore, India

by Benson Samuel

An event at the Centre for Internet & Society (CIS) was organized on January 23, 2013. The all star team at CIS was awesome at organizing this event for Bitcoin. Live streaming, mainstream newspaper coverage and Twitter based Q&A made this the first Bitcoin event in India that leveraged these mediums of information transfer.

Read more →

Don’t SLAPP free speech

by Sunil Abraham

IIPM is proving adept at the tactical use of lawsuits to stifle criticism, despite safeguards. THE DEPARTMENT of Telecommunications, on 14 February, issued orders to block certain web pages critical of the Indian Institute of Planning and Management (IIPM).

Read more →

Women in the IT Industry: Request for Data

by Jadine Lannon

For CIS's research on indicators of female economic empowerment in the IT industry in India, we have sent formal request for participation in a short survey to the six largest IT companies based in India. A copy of the letter of request and survey as well as some details of the request for data can be found in this post.

Read more →

Research Initiative: Women in India's IT Industry

by Jadine Lannon

CIS has begun a brief research project which will examine indicators of female economic empowerment in the IT industry in India. Though the gathering of quantitative and qualitative data from the six largest publicly-traded Indian software companies, we hope to provide insight into state of female employment in one of the most important and rapidly growing economic sectors in the country.

Read more →

BigDog is Watching You! The Sci-fi Future of Animal and Insect Drones

by Maria Xynou

Do you think robotic aeroplanes monitoring us are scary enough? Wait until you read about DARPA´s new innovative and subtle way to keep us all under the microscope! This blog post presents a new reality of drones which is depicted in none other than animal and insect-like robots, equipped with cameras and other surveillance technologies.

Read more →

Surveillance Camp IV: Disproportionate State Surveillance - A Violation of Privacy

by Elonnai Hickok

This is the fourth in a series of posts mapping global surveillance challenges discussed at EFF's State Surveillance and Human Rights Camp in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. This article has been co-written with Elonnai Hickok — Centre for Internet and Society India, and a speaker at EFF's Camp.

Read more →

The Omnishambles of UID, shrouded in its RTI opacity

by Elonnai Hickok

The Centre for Internet & Society sponsored Colonel Mathew Thomas to hold a workshop at the fourth National Right to Information (RTI) organized by the National Campaign for People's Right to Information, held in Hyderabad from February 15 to 18, 2013.

Read more →

Freedom of Expression Gagged

by Chinmayi Arun

The use of law to bully people into silence, called ‘heckler’s veto’, is not unique to India, writes Chinmayi Arun in this op-ed published in Business Line on February 15, 2013.

Read more →

Analyzing the Latest List of Blocked URLs by Department of Telecommunications (IIPM Edition)

by Snehashish Ghosh

The Department of Telecommunications (DoT) in its order dated February 14, 2013 has issued directions to the Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to block seventy eight URLs. The block order has been issued as a result of a court order. Snehashish Ghosh does a preliminary analysis of the list of websites blocked as per the DoT order.

Read more →

A Comparison of Indian Legislation to Draft International Principles on Surveillance of Communications

by Elonnai Hickok

This blog post is a comparison of the relevant Indian legislations allowing governmental access to communications and the Draft International Principles on Surveillance of Communications. The principles, first drafted in October 2012 and developed subsequently seeks to establish an international standard for surveillance of communications in the context of human rights.

Read more →

Data Retention in India

by Elonnai Hickok

As part of its privacy research, the Centre for Internet and Society has been researching upon data retention mandates from the Government of India and data retention practices by service providers. Globally, data retention has become a contested practice with regards to privacy, as many governments require service providers to retain more data for extensive time periods, for security purposes. Many argue that the scope of the retention is becoming disproportional to the purpose of investigating crimes.

Read more →

Five Frequently Asked Questions about the Amended ITRs

by Chinmayi Arun

This piece discusses the five major questions that have been the subject of debate after the World Conference on International Telecommunications 2012 (WCIT). The politics surrounding the WCIT are not discussed here but it must be kept in mind that they have played a significant role in the outcome of the conference and in some of the debates about it.

Read more →

TV versus Social Media: The Rights and Wrongs

by Sunil Abraham

For most ordinary Netizens, everyday speech on social media has as much impact as graffiti in a toilet, and therefore employing the 'principle of equivalence' will result in overregulation of new media.

Read more →

Web of Sameness

by Nishant Shah

The social Web has been an ominous space at the start of 2013. It has been awash with horror, pain and grief. The recent gang rape and death of a medical student in Delhi prevents one from being too optimistic about the year to come. My live feeds on various social networks are filled with rue and rage at the gruesome incident and the seeming depravity of our society.

Read more →

Draft International Principles on Communications Surveillance and Human Rights

by Elonnai Hickok

These principles were developed by Privacy International and the Electronic Frontier Foundation and seek to define an international standard for the surveillance of communications. The Centre for Internet and Society has been contributing feedback to the principles.

Read more →

Statement of Solidarity on Freedom of Expression and Safety of Internet Users in Bangladesh

by Pranesh Prakash

This is a statement on the violent attack on blogger Asif Mohiuddin by the participants to the Third South Asian Meeting on the Internet and Freedom of Expression that took place in Dhaka, Bangladesh, on January 14–15, 2013.

Read more →

No Civil Society Members in the Cyber Regulations Advisory Committee

by Pranesh Prakash

The Government of India has taken our advice and reconstituted the Cyber Regulations Advisory Commitee. But there is no representation of Internet users, citizens, and consumers — only government and industry interests.

Read more →

Mining the Web Collective

by Sharath Chandra Ram

In March 2012, Dr Bruno Latour and his team from the Sciences Po Media Lab organized a workshop that assembled a selected group of researchers from India to explore methods of Controversy Mapping. It was hosted by Dr J. Srinivasan, Director of the Divecha Centre for Climate Change at the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India.

Read more →

State Surveillance and Human Rights Camp: Summary

by Elonnai Hickok

On December 13 and 14, 2012, the Electronic Frontier Foundation organized the Surveillance and Human Rights Camp held in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The meeting examined trends in surveillance, reasons for state surveillance, surveillance tactics that governments are using, and safeguards that can be put in place to protect against unlawful or disproportionate surveillance.

Read more →

Tomorrow, Today

by Nishant Shah

Our present is the future that our past had imagined. Around the same time last year, I remember taking stock of the technologies that we live with and wondering what 2012 would bring in.

Read more →

Internet-driven Developments — Structural Changes and Tipping Points

by Elonnai Hickok

A symposium on Internet Driven Developments: Structural Changes and Tipping Points was held in Cambridge, Massachusetts at Harvard University from December 6 to 8, 2012. The symposium was sponsored by the Ford Foundation and the MacArthur Foundation and was hosted by the Berkman Center for Internet & Society. In this blog post, I summarize the discussions that took place over the two days and add my own personal reflections on the issues.

Read more →

The Trouble with Hurried Solutions

by Chinmayi Arun

The World Conference on International Telecommunication showed that countries are not yet ready to arrive at a consensus on regulation and control of the Internet

Read more →

The Worldwide Web of Concerns

by Pranesh Prakash

The Intern­ati­onal Telec­om­munication Union’s World Conference on International Telecommunications (WCIT-12) is currently under way in Dubai, after a gap of 25 years. At this conference, the Inter-national Teleco­mmunication Regulations — a binding treaty containing high-level principles — are to be revised.

Read more →

The Worldwide Web of Concerns

by Pranesh Prakash

The threat of a ‘UN takeover’ of the Internet through the WCIT is non-existent. However, that does not mean that activists have been crying themselves hoarse in vain.

Read more →

Online Censorship: How Government should Approach Regulation of Speech

by Sunil Abraham

Why is there a constant brouhaha in India about online censorship? What must be done to address this?

Read more →

Comments on the Proposed Rule 138A of the Central Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989 Concerning Radio Frequency Identification Tags

by Bhairav Acharya

The Centre for Internet & Society gave its comments on the proposed Rule 138A of the Central Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989. The comments were made in response to Notification GSR 738(E) published in the Gazette of India on October 3, 2012.

Read more →

Section 66-A, Information Technology Act, 2000: Cases

by Snehashish Ghosh

In this blog post Snehashish Ghosh summarizes the facts of a few cases where Section 66-A, Information Technology Act, 2000, has been mentioned or discussed.

Read more →

Transcripts from WCIT-12

by Snehashish Ghosh

We are archiving copies of the live-transcripts from the World Conference on International Telecommunications, 2012 (WCIT-12) which is being held in Dubai from 3–14 December, 2012.

Read more →

So Much to Lose

by Nishant Shah

Unless you have been hiding under a rock, you have been a witness to the maelstrom of events that accompanied the death of the political leader Bal Thackeray.

Read more →

Fixing India’s anarchic IT Act

by Pranesh Prakash

Section 66A of the Information Technology (IT) Act criminalizes “causing annoyance or inconvenience” online, among other things. A conviction for such an offence can attract a prison sentence of as many as three years.

Read more →

Breaking Down Section 66A of the IT Act

by Pranesh Prakash

Section 66A of the Information Technology Act, which prescribes 'punishment for sending offensive messages through communication service, etc.' is widely held by lawyers and legal academics to be unconstitutional. In this post Pranesh Prakash explores why that section is unconstitutional, how it came to be, the state of the law elsewhere, and how we can move forward.

Read more →

Draft nonsense

by Pranesh Prakash

Seriously flawed and dodgily drafted provisions in the IT Act provide the state a stick to beat its citizens with.

Read more →

DoT Blocks Domain Sites — But Reasons and Authority Unclear

by Smitha Krishna Prasad

Earlier this year, ISPs such as Airtel and MTNL blocked a number of domain sites including BuyDomains, Fabulous Domains and Sedo.co.uk. Whereas the Indian Government and courts have previously issued orders blocking websites, these actions have generally been attributed to issues such as posting of inflammatory content or piracy of copyrighted material. However, the reasoning behind blocking domain marketplaces such as the above mentioned sites is not clear.

Read more →

Arbitrary Arrests for Comment on Bal Thackeray's Death

by Pranesh Prakash

Two girls have been arbitrarily and unlawfully arrested for making comments about the late Shiv Sena supremo Bal Thackeray's death. Pranesh Prakash explores the legal angles to the arrests.

Read more →

Will The International Telecommunication Regulations (ITRs) Impact Internet Governance? A Multistakeholder Perspective

by Pranesh Prakash

Pranesh Prakash made a presentation at the India Internet Governance Conference (IIGC) held at the FICCI, Federation House, Tansen Marg, New Delhi on October 4 and 5, 2012. The event was organised by the Ministry of Communications & Information Technology, FICCI and Internet Society. CIS was one of the supporting organisations.

Read more →

Statement of Civil Society Members and Groups Participating in the "Best Bits" pre-IGF meeting at Baku in 2012

by Pranesh Prakash

The Centre for Internet & Society was one of the signatories for this submission made to the ITU on November 16, 2012.

Read more →

Q&A to the Report of the Group of Experts on Privacy

by Elonnai Hickok

In January 2012 Justice A.P. Shah formed a committee consisting of a group of experts to contribute to and create a report of recommendations for a privacy legislation in India. The committee met a total of seven times from January to September 2012. The Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) was a member of the committee creating the report. This blog post is CIS’s attempt to answer questions that have arisen from media coverage on the report, based on our understanding.

Read more →

Indian Government's Submission to ITU

by Pranesh Prakash

The following is the text of the submission made by the Government of India to the World Conference of International Telecommunications, Dubai on November 3, 2012. This is the final version of a draft that was circulated earlier.

Read more →

Submission on India's Draft Comments on Proposed Changes to the ITU's ITRs

by Pranesh Prakash

Given below are the responses from the representatives of civil society in India (The Society for Knowledge Commons, Centre for Internet & Society, The Delhi Science Forum, Free Software Movement of India, Internet Democracy Project and Media for Change) to the Government of India's proposals for the upcoming WCIT meeting, in December 2012, in Dubai.

Read more →

Submission by Indian Civil Society Organisations on Proposals for the Future ITRs and Related Processes

by Pranesh Prakash

The Centre for Internet & Society was one of the signatories of this submission which was sent in November 2012, in response to the International Telecommunication Union's call for public comments in relation to the revision of International Telecommunication Regulations that are to take place at the ITU's World Conference on International Telecommunications in Dubai from December 3 to 14, 2012.

Read more →

Rethinking DNA Profiling in India

by Elonnai Hickok

DNA profile databases can be useful tools in solving crime, but given that the DNA profile of a person can reveal very personal information about the individual, including medical history, family history and so on, a more comprehensive legislation regulating the collection, use, analysis and storage of DNA samples needs included in the draft Human DNA Profiling Bill.

Read more →

Privacy Perspectives on the 2012 -2013 Goa Beach Shack Policy

by Elonnai Hickok

CCTVs in India are increasingly being employed by private organizations and the government in India as a way to increase security and prevent/ deter crime from taking place. When the government mandates the use of CCTV’s for this purpose, it often does so by means of a blunt policy mandate, requiring the installation of CCTV systems, but without any further clarification as to who should oversee the use of the cameras, what bodies should have access to the records, how access should be granted or obtained, and how long the recordings should be retained.

Read more →

A Public Meeting on DNA Profiling Bill in Delhi

by Elonnai Hickok

On September 27, 2012, the Centre for Internet and Society hosted a public talk at the Indian International Centre focused on the draft DNA Profiling Bill. Presenting at the meeting were international experts Dr. Helen Wallace, director of GeneWatch UK and Jeremy Gruber, president and executive director of the Council for Responsible Genetics US, and Dr. Anupuma Raina, senior scientist at AIIMs.

Read more →

India's Internet Jam

by Pranesh Prakash

As authorities continue to clamp down on digital freedom, politicians and corporations are getting a taste for censorship too. Pranesh Prakash reports.

Read more →

Analysing Latest List of Blocked Sites (Communalism & Rioting Edition)

by Pranesh Prakash

Pranesh Prakash does preliminary analysis on a leaked list of the websites blocked from August 18, 2012 till August 21, 2012 by the Indian government.

Read more →

Privacy Matters — Medical Privacy

by Natasha Vaz

On June 30, 2012, Privacy India in partnership with the Indian Network for People living with HIV/AIDS, Centre for Internet & Society, IDRC, Society in Action Group, with support from London-based Privacy International, held a public discussion on "Medical Privacy" at the Yashwantrao Chavan Academy of Development Administration.

Read more →

India's Broken Internet Laws Need a Shot of Multi-stakeholderism

by Pranesh Prakash

Cyber-laws in India are severely flawed, with neither lawyers nor technologists being able to understand them, and the Cyber-Law Group in DEIT being incapable of framing fair, just, and informed laws and policies. Pranesh Prakash suggests they learn from the DEIT's Internet Governance Division, and Brazil, and adopt multi-stakeholderism as a core principle of Internet policy-making.

Read more →

Statutory Motion Against Intermediary Guidelines Rules

by Pranesh Prakash

Rajya Sabha MP, Shri P. Rajeev has moved a motion that the much-criticised Intermediary Guidelines Rules be annulled.

Read more →

How India Makes E-books Easier to Ban than Books (And How We Can Change That)

by Pranesh Prakash

Without getting into questions of what should and should not be unlawful speech, Pranesh Prakash chooses to take a look at how Indian law promotes arbitrary removal and blocking of websites, website content, and online services, and how it makes it much easier than getting offline printed speech removed.

Read more →

Press Coverage of Online Censorship Row

by Pranesh Prakash

We are maintaining a rolling blog with press references to the row created by the proposal by the Union Minister for Communications and Information Technology to pre-screen user-generated Internet content.

Read more →

India's Statement Proposing UN Committee for Internet-Related Policy

by Pranesh Prakash

This is the statement made by India at the 66th session of the United Nations General Assembly, in which its proposal for the UN Committee for Internet-Related Policy was presented.

Read more →

Analysis of DIT's Response to Second RTI on Website Blocking

by Pranesh Prakash

In this blog post, Pranesh Prakash briefly analyses the DIT's response to an RTI request on website blocking alongside the most recent edition of Google's Transparency Report, and what it tells us about the online censorship regime in India.

Read more →

Sixth Annual Meeting of the Internet Governance Forum, Nairobi: A Summary

by Prasad Krishna

The sixth annual meeting of the Internet Governance Forum was held from 27 to 30 September 2011 at the United Nations Office in Nairobi, Kenya. Sunil Abraham participated in six workshops: Privacy, Security, and Access to Rights: A Technical and Policy Analyses, Use of Digital Technologies for Civic Engagement and Political Change: Lessons Learned and Way Forward, The Impact of Regulation: FOSS and Enterprise, Proprietary Influences in Free and Open Source Software: Lessons to Open and Universal Internet Standards, Access and Diversity of Broadband Internet Access and Putting Users First: How Can Privacy be Protected in Today’s Complex Mobile Ecosystem?

Read more →

Design!Public II in Bangalore ― Event Report

by Yelena Gyulkhandanyan

Design Public, a high-level conclave on innovation, took place in Bangalore at the National Gallery for Modern Art on October 14, 2011. The event was organized by the Centre for Knowledge Societies in collaboration with the Centre for Internet and Society, the Centre for Law and Policy Research, Mint, and others. The conclave brought together industry experts, scholars, and activists to create a dialogue about design and innovation in the public interest. This blog post captures the developments as it happened on this day.

Read more →

SCOSTA and UID Comparison not Valid, says Finance Committee

by Elonnai Hickok

The Standing Committee on Finance Branch, Lok Sabha Secretariat has responded to the suggestions offered by CIS on the National Identification Authority of India, Bill 2010 and has requested it to mail its views by 14 October 2011.

Read more →

Seventh Open Letter to the Finance Committee: A Note on the Deduplication of Unique Identifiers

by Prasad Krishna

Sahana Sarkar on behalf of the Centre for Internet and Society (CIS) had sent in a Right to Information application on 30 June 2011 to Ashish Kumar, Central Public Information Officer, UIDAI. The UIDAI sent in its reply. Through the seventh open letter, Hans attempts to characterize in an abstract way the replies that CIS managed to elicit and makes some elementary observations.

Read more →

UID: Questions without Answers – A Talk by Usha Ramanathan

by Natasha Vaz

UID enrolment is in full swing, providing an official identification to millions of Indians, yet there are numerous unanswered questions. A public talk on UID was held at the Institute of Science, Bangalore on September 6, 2011. Usha Ramanathan, an independent law researcher on jurisprudence, poverty and rights, discussed the questions that plague the UID project and the veil of silence enveloping the answers.

Read more →

Whole Body Imaging and Privacy Concerns that Follow

by Srishti Goyal

Law student at the National University of Juridical Sciences, and intern for Privacy India, Srishti Goyal compares, contrasts, and critiques the Whole Body Imaging practices found in the US, the UK, and Australia, and makes recommendations for an Indian regime.

Read more →

CCTV in Universities

by Merlin Oommen

Basic Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) Infrastructure is used to observe movements from a central room, and consists of one or more video cameras that transmit video and audio images to a set of monitors or video recorders.

Read more →

Re-thinking Key Escrow

by Natasha Vaz

Would you make duplicates of your house keys and hand them over to the local police authority? And if so, would you feel safe? Naturally, one would protest this invasion of privacy. Similarly, would it be justified for the government to have a copy of the private key to intercept and decrypt communications? This is the idea behind key escrow; it enables government ‘wiretapping’.

Read more →

UID: Nothing to Hide, Nothing to Fear?

by Shilpa Narani

Isn’t it interesting that authorities ask you about your identity and you end up showing your proof of existence! Isn’t this breaching into one’s personal life? Why so much transparency only from the public side? Why can’t the government be equally transparent to the public?, asks Shilpa Narani.

Read more →

An Overview of DNA Labs in India

by Shilpa Narani

DNA fingerprinting has become the most precise and technologically advanced method for identifying crimes such as murder, kidnapping, robbery and rape. Police and judicial authorities and in some cases even private parties retain this in their records, writes Shilpa in this blog post.

Read more →

Consumer Privacy in e-Commerce

by Sahana Sarkar

Looking at the larger picture of national security versus consumer privacy, Sahana Sarkar says that though consumer privacy is important in the world of digital technology, individuals must put aside some of their civil liberties when it comes to the question of national security, as it is necessary to prevent societal damage.

Read more →

Video Surveillance and Its Impact on the Right to Privacy

by Vaishnavi Chillakuru

The need for video surveillance has grown in this technologically driven era as a mode of law enforcement. Video Surveillance is very useful to governments and law enforcement to maintain social control, recognize and monitor threats, and prevent/investigate criminal activity. In this regard it is pertinent to highlight that not only are governments using this system, but residential communities in certain areas are also using this system to create a safer environment.

Read more →

Privacy Matters, Guwahati — Event Report

by Prasad Krishna

On June 23, a public seminar on “Privacy Matters” was held at the Don Bosco Institute in Karhulli, Guwahati. It was organised by IDRC, Society in Action Group, IDEA Chirang, an NGO initiative working with grassroots initiatives in Assam, Privacy India and CIS and was attended by RTI activists and grass roots NGO representatives from across the North Eastern region: Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh, Tripura, Nagaland, Assam and Sikkim. The event focused on the challenges and concerns of privacy in India.

Read more →

Right to Privacy Bill 2010 — A Few Comments

by Elonnai Hickok

Earlier this year, in February 2011, Rajeev Chandrasekhar introduced the Right to Privacy Bill, 2010 in the Rajya Sabha. The Bill is meant to “provide protection to the privacy of persons including those who are in public life”. Though the Bill states that its objective is to protect individuals’ fundamental right to privacy, the focus of the Bill is on the protection against the use of electronic/digital recording devices in public spaces without consent and for the purpose of blackmail or commercial use.

Read more →

Privacy & Media Law

by Sonal Makhija

In her research, Sonal Makhija, a Bangalore-based lawyer, tries to delineate the emerging privacy concerns in India and the existing media norms and guidelines on the right to privacy. The research examines the existing media norms (governed by Press Council of India, the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995 and the Code of Ethics drafted by the News Broadcasting Standard Authority), the constitutional protection guaranteed to an individual’s right to privacy upheld by the courts, and the reasons the State employs to justify the invasion of privacy. The paper further records, both domestic and international, inclusions and exceptions with respect to the infringement of privacy.

Read more →

When Data Means Privacy, What Traces Are You Leaving Behind?

by Noopur Raval

How do you know yourself to be different from others? What defines the daily life that you live and the knowledge you produce in the span of this life? Is all that information yours or are you a mere stakeholder on behalf of the State whose subject you are? What does privacy really mean? In a society that is increasingly relying on information to identify people, collecting and archiving ‘personal’ details of your lives, your name, age, passport details, ration card number, call records etc, how private is your tweet, status update, text message or simply, your restaurant bill?

Read more →

My Experiment with Scam Baiting

by Sahana Sarkar

Today, as I am sure many of you have experienced, Internet scams are widespread and very deceptive. As part of my research into privacy and the Internet, I decided to follow a scam and attempt to fully understand how Internet scams work, and what privacy implications they have for Internet users. Though there are many different types of scams that take place over the Internet —identity scams, housing scams, banking scams— just to name a few. I decided to look in depth at the lottery scam.

Read more →

RTI and Third Party Information: What Constitutes the Private and Public?

by Noopur Raval

The passing of the Right to Information Act, 2005 was seen as giving an empowering tool in the hands of the citizens of India, six years post its implementation, loopholes have surfaced with misuse of the many fundamental concepts, which have yet not been defined to allow for a consistent pattern of decisions. Among many problems that emerge with the Act, a major problem is defining the extent to which an individual has access to other people’s information. While most of us tend to think that asking for other people’s phone numbers, personal details like passport number or IT returns are private and would be kept so, under the RTI Act and as seen in the Central Information Commission (CIC) decisions, all of these details can be availed of by someone who doesn’t know you at all!

Read more →

Privacy and Security Can Co-exist

by Sunil Abraham

The blanket surveillance the Centre seeks is not going to make India more secure, writes Sunil Abraham in this article published in Mail Today on June 21, 2011.

Read more →

Copyright Enforcement and Privacy in India

by Prashant Iyengar

Copyright can function contradictorily, as both the vehicle for the preservation of privacy as well as its abuse, writes Prashant Iyengar. The research examines the various ways in which privacy has been implicated in the shifting terrain of copyright enforcement in India and concludes by examining the notion of the private that emerges from a tapestry view of the relevant sections of Copyright Act.

Read more →

Snooping Can Lead to Data Abuse

by Sunil Abraham

THE NATGRID, aiming to link databases of 21 departments and ministries for better counter-terror measures, adopts blunt policy approach, subjecting every citizen to the same level of blanket surveillance, instead of a targeted approach that intelligently focuses on geographic or demographic areas that are currently important, writes Sunil Abraham in this article published by Mail Today on June 9, 2011.

Read more →

The New Right to Privacy Bill 2011 — A Blind Man's View of the Elephunt

by Prashant Iyengar

Over the past few days various newspapers have reported the imminent introduction in Parliament, during the upcoming Monsoon session, of a Right to Privacy Bill. Since the text of this bill has not yet been made accessible to the public, this post attempts to grope its way – through guesswork – towards a picture of what the Bill might look like from a combined reading of all the newspaper accounts, writes Prashant Iyengar in this blog post which was posted on the Privacy India website on June 8, 2011.

Read more →

Do You Want to be Watched?

by Sunil Abraham

The new rules under the IT Act are an assault on our freedom, says Sunil Abraham in this article published in Pragati on June 8, 2011.

Read more →

The Digital is Political

by Nishant Shah

Technologies are not just agents of politics, there is politics in their design, writes Nishant Shah in this article published in Down to Earth in the Issue of June 15, 2011.

Read more →

Say 'Password' in Hindi

by Nishant Shah

English might be the language of the online world, but it’s time other languages had their say, writes Nishant Shah. The article was published in the Indian Express on June 5, 2011.

Read more →

A Street View of Private and the Public

by Prashant Iyengar

Prashant Iyengar on how in the eyes of the law, the internet giant is like the homeless in India. This article was published by Tehelka on June 4, 2011.

Read more →

Bloggers' Rights Subordinated to Rights of Expression: Cyber Law Expert

by Elonnai Hickok

Vijayashankar, an eminent cyber law expert answers Elonnai Hickok’s questions on bloggers' rights, freedom of expression and privacy in this e-mail interview conducted on May 19, 2011.

Read more →

Big Brother is Watching You

by Sunil Abraham

The government is massively expanding its surveillance power over law-abiding citizens and businesses, says Sunil Abraham in this article published by the Deccan Herald on June 1, 2011.

Read more →

The Present — and Future — Dangers of India's Draconian New Internet Regulations

by Anja Kovacs

The uproar surrounding India's Internet Control Rules makes clear that in the Internet age, as before, the active chilling of freedom of expression by the state is unacceptable in a democracy. Yet if India's old censorship regimes are to be maintained in this new context, the state will have little choice but to do just that. Are we ready to rethink the ways in which we deal with free speech and censorship as a society? Asks Anja Kovacs in this article, published in Caravan, 1 June 2011.

Read more →

Killing the Internet Softly with Its Rules

by Pranesh Prakash

While regulation of the Internet is a necessity, the Department of IT, through recent Rules under the IT Act, is guilty of over-regulation. This over-regulation is not only a bad idea, but is unconstitutional, and gravely endangers freedom of speech and privacy online.

Read more →

Power to the People

by Nishant Shah

The digital revolution has helped make NGOs and civil society more influential, independent and transparent, writes Nishant Shah in this article published in the Indian Express on Sunday, May 15, 2011.

Read more →

Rebuttal of DIT's Misleading Statements on New Internet Rules

by Pranesh Prakash

The press statement issued on May 11 by the Department of Information Technology (DIT) on the furore over the newly-issued rules on 'intermediary due diligence' is misleading and is, in places, plainly false. We are presenting a point-by-point rebuttal of the DIT's claims.

Read more →

Limits to Privacy

by Prashant Iyengar

In his research article, Prashant Iyengar examines the limits to privacy for individuals in light of the provisions of the Constitution of India, public interest, security of state and maintenance of law and order. The article attempts to build a catalogue of all these justifications and arrive at a classification of all such frequently used terms invoked in statutes and upheld by courts to deprive persons of their privacy.

Read more →

Privacy By Design — Conference Report

by Prasad Krishna

How do we imagine privacy? How is privacy being built into technological systems? On April 16th,The Center for Internet and Society hosted Privacy by Design, an Open Space meant to answer these questions and more around the topic of privacy. Below is a summary of the conversations and dialogs from the event.

Read more →

CDT Provides Answers to Questions on Internet Neutrality

by Pranesh Prakash

Pranesh Prakash of CIS asked David Sohn of CDT a few pointed questions on the emerging hot topic of 'Internet neutrality', and received very useful responses. Those questions and Mr. Sohn's responses are documented in this blog post.

Read more →

The DNA Profiling Bill 2007 and Privacy

by Elonnai Hickok

In 2007 a bill known as the Draft DNA Profiling Bill was piloted by the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics, an autonomous organization funded by the Department of Biotechnology, Ministry of Science and Technology, Government of India. The below is a background to DNA collection/analysis in India, and a critique of the Bill a from a privacy perspective.

Read more →

An Interview with Activist Shubha Chacko: Privacy and Sex Workers

by Elonnai Hickok

On February 20th I had the opportunity to speak with Shubha Chacko on privacy and sex workers. Ms. Chacko is an activist who works for Aneka, an NGO based in Bangalore, which fights for the human rights of sexual minorities. In my interview with Ms. Chacko I tried to understand how privacy impacts the lives of sex workers in India. The below is an account of our conversation.

Read more →

We are anonymous, we are legion

by Sunil Abraham

Online anonymity is vital for creativity and entrepreneurship on the Web, writes Sunil Abraham. The article was published in the Hindu on April 18, 2011.

Read more →

You Have the Right to Remain Silent

by Anja Kovacs

India has a long history of censorship that it justifies in the name of national security. But new laws governing the Internet are unreasonable and — given the multitude of online voices — poorly thought out, argues Anja Kovacs in this article published in the Sunday Guardian on 17 April 2011.

Read more →

Iraq Delegation to Visit India for Study of E-Governance in Indian Cities ― Meetings in Bangalore and Delhi

by Prasad Krishna

An Iraqi Government delegation headed by HE Mr. Abdul Kareem Al-Samarai, Minister of Science & Technology, Government of Iraq will be in India on a e-governance tour. The study tour is organised by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and the Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (ESCWA).

Read more →

Privacy and the Information Technology Act — Do we have the Safeguards for Electronic Privacy?

by Prashant Iyengar

How do the provisions of the Information Technology Act measure up to the challenges of privacy infringement? Does it provide an adequate and useful safeguard for our electronic privacy? Prashant Iyengar gives a comprehensive analysis on whether and how the Act fulfils the challenges and needs through a series of FAQs while drawing upon real life examples.

Read more →

DIT's Response to RTI on Website Blocking

by Pranesh Prakash

For the first time in India, we have a list of websites that are blocked by order of the Indian government. This data was received from the Department of Information Technology in response to an RTI that CIS filed. Pranesh Prakash of CIS analyzes the implications of these blocks, as well as the shortcomings of the DIT's response.

Read more →

Is Data Protection Enough?

by Elonnai Hickok

The following note looks briefly at different sides of the privacy debate, and asks the question whether a Data Protection law is enough privacy protection for India.

Read more →

Surveillance Technologies

by Elonnai Hickok

The following post briefly looks at different surveillance technologies, and the growing use of the them in India.

Read more →

Encryption Standards and Practices

by Elonnai Hickok

The below note looks at different types of encryption, varying practices of encryption in India, and the relationship between encryption, data security, and national security.

Read more →

'Privacy Matters', Ahmedabad: Conference Report

by Prasad Krishna

On 26 March 2011, civil society, lawyers, judges, students and NGO’s, gathered together at the Ahmedabad Management Association to take part in 'Privacy Matters' – a public conference organised by Privacy India in partnership with IDRC and Research Foundation for Governance in India (RFGI) — to discuss the challenges of privacy in India, with an emphasis on national security and privacy. The conference was opened by Prashant Iyengar, head researcher at Privacy India and Kanan Drhu, director of RFGI. Mr. Iyengar explained Privacy India’s mandate to raise awareness of privacy, spark civil action, and promote democratic dialogue around privacy challenges and violations in India. RFGI is a think tank established in 2009 which aims to research, promote, and implement various reforms to improve the legal and political process in Gujarat and across India. ‘Privacy Matters – Ahmedabad’ is the third conference out of the eight that Privacy India will be hosting across India. The next conference will take place in Hyderabad on 9 April 2011. It will focus on human rights and privacy.

Read more →

News Broadcasting Standards Authority censures TV9 over privacy violations!

by Prashant Iyengar

We at PrivacyIndia/CIS are delighted by the recent order issued by the News Broadcasting Standards Authority(NBSA) which slapped a 1 lakh rupee fine on the news channel TV9 for airing an extremely incendiary and invasive programme titled "Gay Culture rampant in Hyderabad".

Read more →

A Stolen Perspective

by Elonnai Hickok

The note below is a perspective piece on biometrics. On March 11th I traveled down to the Philippines, and had a chance to experience the possible convenience of biometric based identification.

Read more →

The Draft Electronic Delivery of Services Bill, 2011 – Comments by CIS

by Prasad Krishna

The Draft Electronic Delivery of Services Bill, 2011 (“Bill”) is a Bill to provide for delivery of government services manadatorily through electronic means by phasing out manual delivery of services. It is heartening to note that the Bill shifts the approach to electronic delivery of services by Government agencies to one as part of the citizens' right to service delivery through electronic means rather than a luxury or benefit doled out by the Government. The Bill introduces bodies exclusively accountable for ensuring that electronic delivery of services by the Government at the state and central levels. While this is a welcome move on the part of the Government there are a few comments we, at the Centre for Internet and Society, have on the present version of the Bill:

Read more →

Policy for Government's Presence in Social Media - Recommendations

by Krithika Dutta Narayana

In pursuance of the Office Memorandum issued by the DIT dated March 4, 2011, the e-Governance Group of the DIT, convened on March 23, 2011, the first meeting of an exclusive group to propose guidelines for government presence on social networking and social media sites. The Centre for Internet and Society being one of the invitees to the meeting, has submitted its recommendations for a Policy for the Government's presence in social networking and social media sites.

Read more →

Privacy and Governmental Databases

by Elonnai Hickok

In our research we have found that most government databases are incrementally designed in response to developments and improvements that need to be incorporated from time to time. This method of architecting a system leads to a poorly designed database with many privacy risks such as: inaccurate data, incomplete data, inappropriate disclosure of data, inappropriate access to data, and inappropriate security over data. To address these privacy concerns it is important to analyze the problem that is being addressed from the perspective of potential and planned interoperability with other government databases. Below is a list of problems and recommendations concerning privacy, concerning government databases.

Read more →

RTI Applications on Blocking of Websites

by Pranesh Prakash

In recent weeks, an increasing number of incidents have come to light on government-ordered blocking of websites. In one case involving Zone-H.org, it is clear who has ordered the block (a Delhi district court judge, as an interim order), even though the block itself is open to constitutional challenge. In all others cases, including the TypePad case, it is unclear who has ordered the block and why. We at CIS have sent in two right to information requests to find out.

Read more →

CIS Para-wise Comments on Intermediary Due Diligence Rules, 2011

by Pranesh Prakash

On February 7th 2011, the Department of Information Technology, MCIT published draft rules on its website (The Information Technology (Due diligence observed by intermediaries guidelines) Rules, 2011) in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 87(2)(zg), read with Section 79(2) of the Information Technology Act, 2000. Comments were invited from the public before February 25th 2011. Accordingly, Privacy India and Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore have prepared the following para-wise comments for the Ministry’s consideration.

Read more →

CIS Para-wise Comments on Cyber Café Rules, 2011

by Prashant Iyengar

On February 7th 2011, the Department of Information Technology, MCIT published draft rules on its website (The Information Technology (Guidelines for Cyber Cafe) Rules, 2011) in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 87(2) (zg), read with Section 79(2) of the Information Technology Act, 2000. Comments were invited from the public before February 25th 2011. Accordingly, Privacy India and Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore have prepared the following para wise comments for the Ministry’s consideration.

Read more →

CIS Para-wise Comments on Draft Reasonable Security Practices Rules, 2011

by Prashant Iyengar

On February 7th 2011, the Department of Information Technology, MCIT published draft rules on its website (The Information Technology (Reasonable security practices and procedures and sensitive personal information) Rules, 2011) in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 87(2)(ob), read with Section 43A of the Information Technology Act, 2000. Comments were invited from the public before February 25th 2011. Accordingly, Privacy India and Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore have prepared the following para-wise comments for the Ministry’s consideration.

Read more →

Google Policy Fellowship Program: Asia Chapter

by Prasad Krishna

For the ardent followers of free and open Internet and for those who love to debate on technology, media law and Internet-related policy issues, there is some good news. The Centre for Internet and Society, India is conducting a Google Policy Fellowship program this summer!

Read more →

Open Letter to the Finance Committee: UID and Transactions

by Prasad Krishna

Since official documentation from the UIDAI is very limited, we assume that data pertaining to transactions would comprise of the Aadhaar number, identifier of the authenticating device, date-time stamp, and approval/rejection/error code. Recording and maintaining of data pertaining to transactions is very important because it increases transparency and accountability through an audit trail. However, storage of such sensitive data creates many privacy risks, because more often than not metadata gives you as much intelligence as raw data.

Read more →

Open Letter to the Finance Committee: Operational Design

by Prasad Krishna

The objective of the UID project is to provide identity infrastructure that is not susceptible to fraud or error. This note highlights parts of the operational design of the project, which are flawed. We plead that each point be taken into consideration and that the design be suitably revised.

Read more →

Open Letter to the Finance Committee: UID Budget

by Prasad Krishna

This note presents the aspects of the UID project, which have not been considered or incorporated into the UID’s budget. The costs include re-enrollment, loss in human time, and the cost of the audit function.

Read more →

Open Letter to the Finance Committe: Biometrics

by Prasad Krishna

This note points out the weaknesses inherent in biometrics and the pitfalls in using them. It recommends procedural safeguards that should be adopted by the UID in order to make the use of biometrics more secure and inclusive.

Read more →

Open Letter to the Finance Committee: Finance and Security

by Prasad Krishna

This note explores the three connections between finance and security and demonstrates the cost implications of operating a centrally designed identity management system as proposed by the UID. In doing so, it shows how the monitoring, storing, and securing of transactional data in a centralized database fall short of meeting the project's objectives of authentication, and thus is an additional cost. Further, it is argued that the blanket monitoring of the transaction database is not an effective method of detecting fraud, and is an expensive component of the project.

Read more →

Conference Report: 'Privacy Matters' Bangalore

by Prasad Krishna

On February 5th the 'Privacy Matters" conference was held at the TERI Regional Center in Bangalore. The event was a full day and centered around issues of privacy including: privacy rights of minorities, privacy and open government data, and privacy and identity.

Read more →

Analysing the Right to Privacy and Dignity with Respect to the UID

by Deva Prasad

In the below note, Deva Prasad, LLM Candidate at NLSIU, explores the challenges that the UID project faces from a legal perspective.

Read more →

Privacy Matters — Conference Report

by Prasad Krishna

A one-day conference on Privacy Matters was held on Sunday, 23 January 2011 at the National University of Juridical Sciences (NUJS) Law School in Kolkata. This was the first of a series of eleven conferences on ‘privacy’ that Privacy India is scheduled to host in different Indian cities from January to June this year. Members of Parliament, Sri Manoj Bhattacharya from the Revolutionary Socialist Party (RSP) and Sri Nilotpal Basu from the Communist Party of India (Marxist) CPI (M) spoke in the conference. Students, the civil society and lawyers also participated in it.

Read more →

Privacy Matters Conference Agenda

by Prasad Krishna

The "Privacy Matters" conference is taking place on Sunday January 23rd, at NUJS Law school at 10:30. It is a full day event that will discuss the challenges and concerns of privacy in India. Below is the agenda for the event. We look forward to your participation and attendance.

Read more →

Jurisdictional Issues in Cyberspace

by Justice S Muralidhar

This article by Justice S Muralidhar was published in the Indian Journal of Law and Technology, Volume 6, 2010. It explores in detail the jurisdiction of courts when dealing with disputes arising from commercial transactions on the Internet.

Read more →

An Open Letter to the Finance Committee: SCOSTA Standards

by Elonnai Hickok

The UID Bill has been placed to the Finance Committee for review and approval. Through a series of open letters to the Finance Committee, civil society is asking the committee to take into consideration and change certain aspects of the Bill and the project. The below note compares the SCOSTA standard with the Aadhaar biometric standard, and explains why we believe the SCOSTA standard should replace the Aadhaar biometric standard for the authentication process in the UID scheme.

Read more →

Does the UID Reflect India?

by Elonnai Hickok

On December 17th the Campaign for No UID held a press conference and public meeting in Bangalore. Below is a summary and analysis of the events.

Read more →

The Privacy Rights of Whistleblowers

by Elonnai Hickok

The recent disclosures from Wikileaks have shown that the right to information, whistle-blowing, and privacy are interconnected. This note looks at the different ways in which the three are related, as well as looking at the benefits and drawbacks to Wikileaks in terms of privacy.

Read more →

UID & Privacy - A Call for Papers

by Elonnai Hickok

Privacy India is inviting individuals to author short papers focused on Unique Identity (UID) and Privacy. Selected candidates will have their papers published on the CIS website, and their transportation and accommodation provided for the “Privacy Matters” conference being held in Kolkata on 22 January 2010.

Read more →

Should Ratan Tata be Afforded the Right to Privacy?

by Elonnai Hickok

The Ratan Tata case has raised many important questions pertaining to privacy. This note looks at a few of those questions, and the debate that centers around them.

Read more →

UID Meeting in Bangalore – A Report

by Prasad Krishna

On 23 November 2010 a public meeting was held for the UID in Bangalore. The speakers included B.K Chandrashekar, former Chairman of the Karnataka Legislature Council, Mr. Vidyashankar, Principal Secretary to Government of e-commerce, Sunil Abraham, Executive Director of Centre for Internet and Society, Jude D’Souza, Technology Specialist and Mathew Thomas, Retired Army Officer.

Read more →

DSCI Information Security Summit 2010 – A Report

by Elonnai Hickok

On 2 and 3 December 2010, the DSCI Information Security Summit 2010 took place in the Trident Hotel, Chennai. The two day summit included a broad spectrum of speakers/panels and topics, ranging from Securing Data & Systems to how to leverage the Cloud. The key speakers were Mr. Gulshan Rai, Director General, CERT-In, DIT, Mr. Rajeev Kapoor, Joint Secretary, DoPT, Govt. of India, Mr. Vakul Sharma, Advocate, Supreme Court of India and Dr. Kamlesh Bajaj, CEO, DSCI. Elonnai Hickok attended the summit.

Read more →

Public Statement to Final Draft of UID Bill

by Elonnai Hickok

The final draft of the UID Bill that will be submitted to the Lok Sabha was made public on 8 November 2010. If the Bill is approved by Parliament, it will become a legal legislation in India. The following note contains Civil Society's response to the final draft of the Bill.

Read more →

Consumer Privacy - How to Enforce an Effective Protective Regime?

by Elonnai Hickok

In a typical sense, when people think of themselves as consumers, they just think about what they purchase, how they purchase and how they use their purchase. But while doing this exercise we are always exchanging personally identifiable information, and thus our privacy is always at risk. In this blog post, Elonnai Hickok and Prashant Iyengar through a series of questions look through the whole concept of consumer privacy at the national and international levels. By placing a special emphasis on Indian context, this post details the potential avenues of consumer privacy in India and states the important elements that should be kept in mind when trying to find at an effective protective regime for consumer privacy.

Read more →

Privacy and Telecommunications: Do We Have the Safeguards?

by Elonnai Hickok

All of you often come across unsolicited and annoying telemarketing calls/ SMS's, prank calls, pestering calls for payment, etc. Do we have any safeguards against them? This blog post takes a look at the various rules and regulations under Indian law to guard our privacy and confidentiality.

Read more →

Privacy and Banking: Do Indian Banking Standards Provide Enough Privacy Protection?

by Elonnai Hickok

Banking is one of the most risky sectors as far as privacy is concerned due to the highly sensitive and personal nature of information which is often exchanged, recorded and retained. Although India has RBI guidelines and legislations to protect data, this blog post looks at the extent of those protections, and what are the areas that still need to be addressed.

Read more →

C.I.S Responds to Privacy Approach Paper

by Elonnai Hickok

A group of officers was created to develop a framework for a privacy legislation that would balance the need for privacy protection, security, sectoral interests, and respond to the domain legislation on the subject. Shri Rahul Matthan of Tri Legal Services prepared an approach paper for the legal framework for a proposed legislation on privacy. The approach paper is now being circulated for seeking opinions of the group of officers and is also being placed on the website of the Department of Personnel and Training for seeking public views on the subject. The Privacy India team at C.I.S responded to the approach paper and has called for the need for a more detailed study of statutory enforcement models and mechanisms in the creation of a privacy legislation.

Read more →

American Bar Association Online Privacy Conference: A Report

by Elonnai Hickok

On 10 November 2010, I attended an American Bar Association online conference on 'Regulating Privacy Across Borders in the Digital Age: An Emerging Global Consensus or Vive la Difference'. The panalists addressed many important global privacy challenges and spoke about the changes the EU directive is looking to take.

Read more →

Privacy, Free/Open Source, and the Cloud

by Elonnai Hickok

A look into the questions that arise in concern to privacy and cloud computing, and how open source plays into the picture.

Read more →

Privacy Concerns in Whole Body Imaging: A Few Questions

by Elonnai Hickok

Security versus Privacy...it is a question that the world is facing today when it comes to using the Whole Body Imaging technology to screen a traveller visually in airports and other places. By giving real life examples from different parts of the world Elonnai Hickok points out that even if the Government of India eventually decides to advocate the tight security measures with some restrictions then such measures need to balanced against concerns raised for personal freedom. She further argues that privacy is not just data protection but something which must be viewed holistically and contextually when assessing new policies.

Read more →

Moldova Online: An Interview with Victor Diaconu

by Sudha Rajagopalan

In this interview for Russian Cyberspace, set up with the help of Sunil Abraham (Executive Director at the Centre for Internet and Society in Bangalore, India), computer software professional Victor Diaconu explains the nature of Internet use, state control and the development of blogging and social media platforms in Moldova. Victor works at Computaris in Chisinau. He is Moldova educated, and has travelled to several western countries (including lengthy stays to US, UK) to learn about and understand what there is to be done in Moldova. Sudha Rajagopalan interviewed Victor Diaconu.

Read more →

Presentation of the UID project by Ashok Dalwai – A Report

by Elonnai Hickok

On Tuesday, 7 September 2010, Ashok Dalwai, the Deputy Director General of the Unique Identification of India (UIDAI), gave a lecture at the Indian Institute for Science in Bangalore. Representing the UID Authority, his presentation explained the vision of the project and focused on the challenges involved in demographic and biometric identification, the technology adopted, and the enrolment process. Elonnai Hickok gives a report of his presentation in this blog post.

Read more →

Beyond Access as Inclusion

by Anja Kovacs

On 13 September, the day before the fifth Internet Governance Forum opens, CIS is coorganising in Vilnius a meeting on Internet governance and human rights. One of the main aims of this meeting is to call attention to the crucial, yet in Internet governance often neglected, indivisibility of rights. In this blog post, Anja Kovacs uses this lens to illustrate how it can broaden as well reinvigorate our understanding of what remains one of the most pressing issues in Internet governance in developing countries to this day: that of access to the Internet.

Read more →

Cybercrime and Privacy

by Prasad Krishna

Elonnai Hickok examines privacy in the context of India’s legal provisions on cybercrime. She picks up the relevant provisions of the Information Technology Act as amended in 2008 dealing with cyber crimes and provides a fair analysis of the pros and cons of the amended Act.

Read more →

Privacy and the Indian Copyright Act

by Prasad Krishna

India's Copyright Act was established in 1957, and is in the process of being placed before the Parliament in 2010. The provisions in the proposed Bill will work to make the Act WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT) compliant. When looking at privacy in the context of copyright four key questions arise, says Elonnai Hickock as she analyses privacy in the context of the Indian Copyright Act.

Read more →

Summary of UID Public Meeting, August 25 2010

by Prasad Krishna

A summary of the "No UID" public meeting that took place on Aug. 25th at the Constitution Club, New Dehli.

Read more →

No UID Campaign in New Delhi - A Report

by Prasad Krishna

The Unique Identification (UID) Bill is not pro-citizen. The scheme is deeply undemocratic, expensive and fraught with unforseen consequences. A public meeting on UID was held at the Constitution Club, Rafi Marg in New Delhi on 25 August, 2010. The said Bill came under scrutiny at the meeting which was organised by civil society groups from Mumbai, Bangalore and Delhi campaigning under the banner of "No UID". The speakers brought to light many concerns, unanswered questions and problems of the UID scheme.

Read more →

Wherever you are, whatever you do

by Sunil Abraham

Facebook recently launched a location-based service called Places. Privacy advocates are resenting to this new development. Sunil Abraham identifies the three prime reasons for this outcry against Facebook. The article was published in the Indian Express on 23 August, 2010.

Read more →

Does the Government want to enter our homes?

by Sunil Abraham

When rogue politicians and bureaucrats are granted unrestricted access to information then the very future of democracy and free media will be in jeopardy. In an article published in the Pune Mirror on 10 August, 2010, Sunil Abraham examines this in light of the BlackBerry-to-BlackBerry messenger service that the Government of India plans to block if its makers do not allow the monitoring of messages. He says that civil society should rather resist and insist on suitable checks and balances like governmental transparency and a fair judicial oversight instead of allowing the government to intrude into the privacy and civil liberties of its citizens.

Read more →

UID Project in India - Some Possible Ramifications

by Liliyan

Having a standard for decentralized ID verification rather than a centralized database that would more often than not be misused by various authorities will solve ID problems, writes Liliyan in this blog entry. These blog posts to be published in a series will voice the expert opinions of researchers and critics on the UID project and present its unique shortcomings to the reader.

Read more →

Civil Liberties and the amended Information Technology Act, 2000

by Malavika Jayaram

This post examines certain limitations of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (as amended in 2008). Malavika Jayaram points out the fact that when most countries of the world are adopting plain English instead of the conventional legal terminology for better understanding, India seems to be stuck in the old-fashioned method thereby, struggling to maintain a balance between clarity and flexibility in drafting its laws. The present Act, she says, is although an improvement over the old Act and seeks to address and improve on certain areas in the right direction but still comes up short in making necessary changes when it comes to fundamental rights and personal liberties. The new Act retains elements from the previous one making it an abnormal document and this could have been averted if there had been some attention to detail.

Read more →

Feedback to the NIA Bill

by Elonnai Hickok

Malavika Jayaram and Elonnai Hickok introduce the formal submission of CIS to the proposed National Identification Authority of India (NIA) Bill, 2010, which would give every resident a unique identity. The submissions contain the detailed comments on the draft bill and the high level summary of concerns with the NIA Bill submitted to the UIDAI on 13 July, 2010.

Read more →

Does the Safe-Harbor Program Adequately Address Third Parties Online?

by Rebecca Schild

While many citizens outside of the US and EU benefit from the data privacy provisions the Safe Harbor Program, it remains unclear how successfully the program can govern privacy practices when third-parties continue to gain more rights over personal data. Using Facebook as a site of analysis, I will attempt to shed light on the deficiencies of the framework for addressing the complexity of data flows in the online ecosystem.

Read more →

Sense and censorship

by Sunil Abraham

Sunil Abraham examines Google's crusade against censorship in China in wake of the attacks on its servers in this article published in the Indian Express.

Read more →

Report on the Fourth Internet Governance Forum for Commonwealth IGF

by Pranesh Prakash

This report by Pranesh Prakash reflects on the question of how useful the IGF is in the light of meetings on the themes of intellectual property, freedom of speech and privacy.

Read more →

When Whistle Blowers Unite

by Sunil Abraham

Leaking corporate or government information in public interest through popular Web service providers is risky but Wikileaks.org is one option that you could try out.

Read more →

Address delivered during the IGF Closing Ceremony

by Radha Rao

This address was delivered by Dr. Anja Kovacs, as a representative of civil society, to the IGF during its closing ceremony.

Read more →

The Role of ICT in Judicial Reform- An Exploration

by Rebecca Schild

A seminar held this month by the Communications and Manufacturing Association of India (CMAI) explored the role that information and communication technology can assume in the process of India's judicial reform efforts. The broad consensus among panelists was that “law is not keeping pace with technology”. However, whether technology will be harnessed to actually facilitate much needed transparency and access to the justice system, or be simply used to improve efficiency within the judicial branch still remains unclear.

Read more →

Information and livelihoods

by Radha Rao

An article by Prof. Subbiah Arunachalam (Distinguished Fellow, CIS) in GISW 2009 (Global Information Society Watch, 2009)

Read more →

IPv6 in India: The promises and challenges

by Pranesh Prakash

Newspapers have been reporting that IPv4 addresses will get over soon, and that we will have to shift to IPv6. In this short piece, Pranesh Prakash gives a layperson's introduction to the IPv6 Internet we will be entering into soon, and what that means for you.

Read more →

Access Beyond Developmentalism: Technology and the Intellectual Life of the Poor

by Radha Rao

Essay by Lawrence Liang, September 21, 2009 in response to - A Dialogue on ICTs, Human Development, Growth, and Poverty Reduction

Read more →

Control Shift?

by Pranesh Prakash

The USA has ceded control of the Internet over to Icann, but only partially. (This post appeared as an article in Down to Earth, in the issue dated November 15, 2009.)

Read more →

The ICANN-US DOC 'Affirmation of Commitments' - A Step Forward?

by Anja Kovacs

On 30 September 2009, ICANN (Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers) signed an Affirmation of Commitments (AoC) with the US Government's Department of Commerce. For those of us who are concerned that the Internet should serve the global public good, is the new arrangement a step forward? An assessment.

Read more →

ಕೃಷಿ ಸಂಪದ - ಇ-ಮ್ಯಾಗಜೀನ್ ಬಿಡುಗಡೆ

by Radha Rao

ಪರಿಸರ ಬರಹಗಾರ ನಾಗೇಶ್ ಹೆಗಡೆ ಅವರು ಕಂಪ್ಯೂಟರಿನ ಸ್ವಿಚ್ ಒತ್ತಿ ಪರದೆಯಲ್ಲಿ ಡಿಜಿಟಲ್ ಪುಟ ಬೆಳಗಿ "ಕೃಷಿ ಸಂಪದ" ಇ-ಮ್ಯಾಗಜೀನನ್ನು ಇಂಟರ್ನೆಟ್ ಲೋಕಕ್ಕೆ ಅರ್ಪಿಸಿದರು.

Read more →

Information and Communication Technology For Improving Agriculture and Rural Livelihoods

by Radha Rao

ಮೈಕೇಲ್, ಮೊಬೈಲ್ ಮತ್ತು ಗ್ರಾಮೀಣ ಅಭಿವೃದ್ಧಿ (ಮೈಕೇಲ್ ರಿಗ್ಸ್ ಭಾಷಣ) - ಚಾಮರಾಜ ಸವಡಿ

Read more →

Value Added Services of Information & Communication Technology- Mobile Telephony for Farmers Benefit

by Radha Rao

Mr. G Raghunatha, State Manager, IFFCO Kisan Sanchar Ltd., Bangalore and Secretary, Institution of Agricultural Technologists, Bangalore has written an article on how ICT - Mobile Technology can be used for the farmers' benefit.

Read more →

A Comment on the 2009 IGF Draft Programme Paper

by Anja Kovacs

The Centre for Internet and Society is part of a broad group of civil society actors that submitted a comment on the Draft Programme Paper of the fourth Internet Governance Forum (IGF), taking place in Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt, in November 2009. The IGF is a forum for multistakeholder policy dialogue on Internet governance issues. The comment decries the complete absence of attention for Internet Rights and Principles in the agenda as it stands as of today, and this despite repeated requests from a wide range of stakeholders to make this theme a central one. All stakeholder groups were invited to submit their comments on the Draft Programme Paper of the 2009 IGF to the IGF Secretariat by 15 August.

Read more →

IT Act and Commerce

by Pranesh Prakash

This is a guest post by Rahul Matthan, partner in the law firm Trilegal, and widely regarded as one of the leading experts on information technology law in India. In this post, Mr. Matthan looks at the provisions in the amended Information Technology Act of interest to commerce, namely electronic signatures and data protection.

Read more →

Primer on the New IT Act

by Pranesh Prakash

With this draft information bulletin, we briefly discuss some of the problems with the Information Technology Act, and invite your comments.

Read more →

Comments on the Draft Rules under the Information Technology Act

by Pranesh Prakash

The Centre for Internet and Society commissioned an advocate, Ananth Padmanabhan, to produce a comment on the Draft Rules that have been published by the government under the Information Technology Act. In his comments, Mr. Padmanabhan highlights the problems with each of the rules and presents specific recommendations on how they can be improved. These comments were sent to the Department of Information and Technology.

Read more →

Letter to ICANN on NCSG

by Pranesh Prakash

The Centre for Internet and Society sent the following mail to ICANN regarding their attempt to impose their own charter for a Noncommercial Stakeholder Group (NCSG), instead of accepting the one drafted by the Noncommercial Users Constituency (NCUC).

Read more →

An Open Letter on Internet Governance to the UN Internet Governance Forum

by Sanchia de Souza

This open letter brings up concerns of democratic deficit in internet governance worldwide, and is addressed to the UN Internet Governance Forum (IGF). It is to be delivered at the IGF's 3rd Annual Meeting at Hyderabad, India, from 3rd to 6th December, 2008. The signatories are Alternative Law Forum, Bangalore, Centre for Internet and Society, Bangalore, Delhi Science Forum, New Delhi, Free Software Foundation - India, IT for Change, Bangalore, and Knowledge Commons, New Delhi.

Read more →

i4D Interview: Social Networking and Internet Access

by Nishant Shah

Nishant Shah, the Director for Research at CIS, was recently interviewed in i4D in a special section looking at Social Networking and Governance, as a lead up to the Internet Governance Forum in December, in the city of Hyderabad.

Read more →